Japanese Yen
Highlights The dollar bounce has further to run. The DXY index could touch 94 before working off oversold conditions. In this environment, yen long positions also provide an attractive hedge. Meanwhile, Japan has stepped back into deflation, with the resurgence in Covid-19 cases constraining activity and consumption spending. A modest rise in real rates will lead to a self-reinforcing upward spiral for the yen. Remain strategically short USD/JPY. Tactical investors can also short EUR/JPY as a trade. Eventually, when global growth picks up, the yen will weaken at the crosses. However, this is less likely in an environment where global yields remain anchored at low levels. We were stopped out of our long silver/short gold position last week. Reinstate. Feature The powerful bounce in global markets from the March lows is morphing into a speculative frenzy. The highlight this week centered on a few stocks, such as GameStop, Blackberry, and AMC Entertainment holdings, that have entered a manic phase. While liquidity conditions remain extremely favorable for risk assets, only a small shift in market sentiment may be required to trigger a reversal. The big risk from a technical perspective is that this reversal might be deeper and longer than most expect, given extremely overbought conditions. The dollar has tended to strengthen as market volatility rises. 2020 saw the rapid accumulation of dollar shorts, as low interest rates squeezed investors into more speculative assets, such as cryptocurrencies (Chart I-1). With these assets now having jumped high into the stratosphere, and dollar-short positioning at a bearish nadir, the nascent bounce in the USD could morph into something bigger. In our report a fortnight ago,1 we argued for a 2%-4% rise, putting 94 on the DXY index within striking distance. Chart I-1Some Signs Of Speculative Froth Chart I-2The Yen Benefits From A Rise In Volatility The yen also generally benefits from rising volatility (Chart I-2). Should a market correction develop, it will provide the necessary catalyst for established long yen positions. Meanwhile, as we argue below, the backdrop in Japan is becoming more deflationary, which is also yen bullish. We are already short USD/JPY in our portfolio and recommend going short EUR/JPY for a trade. The Yen And Global Markets The AUD/JPY rate is extremely sensitive to equity market conditions (Chart I-3). Therefore, one of the ways to play a potential reversal in equity markets and a rise in volatility is to short the AUD/JPY cross. While we certainly recommend this trade tactically, we prefer to express this view via a short EUR/JPY position. There are three main reasons for this. First, despite a significant rally in AUD/JPY, speculators are still very short the cross, as we showed two weeks ago. This is because short USD positions have been expressed in a concentrated number of currencies, including the euro. In a nutshell, speculators are very long EUR/USD and just neutral EUR/JPY (Chart I-4). This favors EUR short positions from a contrarian perspective, compared to AUD. Chart I-3The Yen And Equity Markets Chart I-4Go Short EUR/JPY For A Trade Second, Australia is doing much better in terms of containing the spread of Covid-19, compared to Europe as we argued last week.2 Australian export volumes and prices continue to recover smartly, and the basic balance remains in a healthy surplus. Meanwhile, there is a rising risk that the Covid-19 crisis will hit Europe particularly hard in Q1 this year. Interest rate markets are already beginning to discount this view. Real interest rates in the euro area are collapsing relative to Japan (Chart I-5). This will limit any fixed-income flows into the euro area from Japanese investors. At the margin, this is negative EUR/JPY. Third, given the most recent stimulus out of Europe, the European Central Bank’s (ECB) balance sheet is expanding faster than that of the Bank of Japan (BoJ). This has historically been negative for the EUR/JPY (Chart I-6). Chart I-5EUR/JPY And Real Interest Rates Chart I-6EUR/JPY And Relative Balance Sheets In a nutshell, equity markets are due for a healthy reset. In a similar fashion, a washing out of stale euro long positions will ensure the bull market for 2021 unfolds with higher conviction. Tactical investors can also short EUR/JPY as a trade. Outright short EUR/USD positions also make sense in the near term. The Yen And Japanese Growth Japan has re-entered a debt-deflation spiral, and it is unclear how it will exit this predicament, other than via a rebound in external demand. While it remains our base case that external demand will recover, the yen will be held hostage in the interim to short-term safe-haven inflows, as real rates remain well bid. Like most other economies, Japan is seeing the worst private-sector contraction in decades. For an economy that has held interest rates near zero since the better part of the 90s, this is not good news. Whenever the structural growth rate of the Japanese economy has fallen below interest rates, the trade-weighted yen has staged a powerful rally (Chart I-7). A strong yen, on the back of deficient domestic demand, then leads to a self-fulfilling deflationary spiral. Chart I-7The Story Of Japan In One Chart The latest Bank of Japan (BoJ) meeting was a clear indication that the central bank was out of policy bullets (the central bank left policy largely unchanged). The BoJ began to acknowledge this problem with the end of the Heisei era3 two years ago. A policy review is due in March of this year, but with aggressive stimulus in place since governor Haruhiko Kuroda took helm almost a decade ago, it is difficult to see how any changes could steer Japan out of deflation and towards a 2% inflation target anytime soon. For example, with the BoJ owning 47% of outstanding JGBs, about 80% of ETFs and almost 5% of JREITs, the supply side puts a serious limitation on how much more stimulus the BoJ can provide. As a result, the impulse of the BoJ’s balance sheet could soon begin to fade, especially relative to that of other central banks (Chart I-8). Chart I-8The BoJ's Balance Sheet Could Peak Soon 2% Inflation = Mission Impossible? Most developed economies have not been able to meet their inflation targets over the last decade. While this might change going forward with unprecedented monetary and fiscal stimulus, it will not happen anytime soon. For example, the US is a much more closed economy than Japan and has not been able to maintain a 2% inflation rate since the Global Financial Crisis. This makes the BoJ’s target of 2% a pipe dream in the near future. Strictly looking at the data, the situation is even worse, with Japan having categorically stepped back into deflation (Chart I-9). The three key variables the authorities pay attention to for inflation – Core CPI, the GDP deflator, and the output gap – are all negative or rolling over. In fact, since the financial crisis, prices in Japan have only been able to really rise after a tax hike. Always forgotten is that the overarching theme for prices in Japan is a rapidly falling (and aging) population, leading to deficient demand (Chart I-10). Chart I-9Japan Is Back In Deflation Chart I-10Japan Prices And Demographics This view is corroborated in the inflation swap market. 5, 10, and 20-year inflation swaps in Japan are all depressed (Chart I-11). More importantly, with almost 50% of the Japanese consumption basket in tradeable goods, domestic inflation is as much driven by the influence of the BoJ or demographics, as it is by globalization. Chart I-11Is 2 Percent Inflation Mission Impossible? Fiscal Policy To The Rescue? Chart I-12Falling Consumer Confidence In Japan Most governments have carte blanche on fiscal stimulus. While it is certainly the case that the Japanese government could boost spending via transfer payments, much of this income is more likely to be saved than spent by the private sector. In other words, the savings ratio for workers continues to surge. If consumers were not willing to spend prior to COVID-19,4 they are unlikely to do so under much more uncertain future conditions (Chart I-12). Some of the government’s outlays will certainly go a long way to boosting aggregate demand, since the fiscal multiplier tends to be much larger in a liquidity trap. This will especially be the case for increased social security spending such as child education, construction activity, or the move towards promoting cashless transactions (with a tax rebate). However, there are important near-term offsets. The first is a potential postponement of the Olympics once again for 2021. This will continue to be a drag on Japanese construction activity. Second, the Covid-19 pandemic has severely curtailed tourism in Japan, especially as Niseko and Hakuba, important ski destinations for foreigners, lose inbound momentum. Tourism makes up a non-negligible component of Japanese income. Finally, the labor (and income) dividend from immigration has practically vanished. The Yen Beyond The Near Term Eventually, when global growth picks up, the yen will weaken at the crosses. However, this is less likely in an environment where global yields remain anchored at low levels. Real interest rates are already higher in Japan, and the above factors could meaningfully generate a deflationary impulse. As such, the starting point for yen long positions is already favorable (Chart I-13). Chart I-13The Yen And Relative Interest Rates Chart I-14DXY And USD/JPY Usually Move Together A continued rise in global equity markets is a key risk to our scenario. This will especially favor short dollar positions. However, as a low-beta currency, our contention is that the yen will surely weaken at its crosses, but could strengthen versus the dollar. The yen rises versus the dollar not only during recessions, but during most episodes of broad dollar weakness (Chart I-14). While short EUR/JPY positions will suffer, short USD/JPY bets should still fare well. As such, we remain strategically short USD/JPY. It is rare to find such a “heads I win, tails I do not lose too much” proposition. Housekeeping We were stopped out of our long silver/short gold position for a modest profit of 6%. We have profitably traded silver for almost two years now, and could see a speculative breakout in the metal over the next few months. We recommend reinstating this trade today with the ratio at 71, while maintaining our target at 65 and setting the stop loss at 72.5. We were also stopped out of our long petrocurrency basket versus the euro. With heightened volatility in oil prices, we will be looking to re-establish this trade from lower levels. Chester Ntonifor Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 Please see our Foreign Exchange Strategy report, "Sizing A Potential Dollar Bounce," dated January 15, 2021. 2 Please see our Foreign Exchange and Global Fixed Income Strategy report, "Australia: Regime Change For Bond Yields And Currency," dated January 20, 2021. 3 The Heisei era refers to the period of Japanese history corresponding to the reign of Emperor Akihito, from January 8, 1989 until his abdication on April 30, 2019. 4 Ricardian equivalence suggests in simple terms that public-sector dissaving will encourage private-sector savings. Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1 Chart I-2USD Technicals 2 Recent data in the US have been resilient: US manufacturing activity continues to outperform its peers, with a solid 59.1 print on the Markit PMI for January. The S&P CoreLogic house price index grew by 9.5% year-on-year in November. Consumer confidence remains resilient, with the expectations component surging for the month of January. 4Q GDP came in at an annualized 4% quarter-on-quarter, in line with expectations. The DXY index was flat this week. The latest FOMC meeting reinforced the view that there will be no rush to tighten US monetary policy. Two preconditions for tightening is inflation well above 2% and tight labor market conditions. This suggests the path for least resistance for the US dollar is down, albeit with some near-term consolidation. Report Links: The Dollar In A Blue Wave - January 8, 2021 The Dollar Conundrum And Protection - November 6, 2020 The Dollar In A Market Reset - October 30, 2020 The Euro Chart I-3EUR Technicals 1 Chart I-4EUR Technicals 2 Recent data from the euro area are softening: Manufacturing PMIs are rolling over, with the aggregate index down to 54.7 in January from 55.2. The German IFO Business climate index also softened from 92.1 to 90.1 in January. GfK consumer confidence slipped from -7.3 to -15.6 in February. The euro fell by 0.3% against the US dollar this week. As the broad dollar continues to work off oversold conditions, the euro remains a potent valve to allow for this reset. We are shorting EUR/JPY this week to profit from any setback in risk assets. Report Links: The Dollar Conundrum And Protection - November 6, 2020 Addressing Client Questions - September 4, 2020 On The DXY Breakout, Euro, And Swiss Franc - February 21, 2020 The Japanese Yen Chart I-5JPY Technicals 1 Chart I-6JPY Technicals 2 Recent data from Japan has been disappointing: Departmental store sales fell by 13.7% year-on-year in December. Retail sales are softening overall in Japan. Tokyo CPI will be released overnight and is expected to stay weak. The Japanese yen fell by 0.7% against the US dollar this week. Our highest conviction call over the next one to three months is to be long the yen both versus the dollar and versus the euro. As we discuss in the front section of this report, short USD/JPY is an attractive “heads I win, tails I do not lose too much” bet. Report Links: The Dollar Conundrum And Protection - November 6, 2020 The Near-Term Bull Case For The Dollar - February 28, 2020 Building A Protector Currency Portfolio - February 7, 2020 British Pound Chart I-7GBP Technicals 1 Chart I-8GBP Technicals 2 Recent data out of the UK have been softening: The Markit manufacturing PMI fell from 57.5 to 52.9 in January. 88K jobs were lost in the three months ending November. This pushed up the ILO unemployment rate to 5%. Average weekly earnings rose by 3.6% year-on-year in November. The British pound was flat against the US dollar this week. Post-Brexit relations and Covid-19 vaccinations continue to dominate the news flow in Britain. The latter is progressing, but a difficult adjustment remains for Britain’s exporters. This will add volatility to the pound. We remain short EUR/GBP on valuation grounds. Report Links: The Dollar Conundrum And Protection - November 6, 2020 Revisiting Our High-Conviction Trades - September 11, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Australian Dollar Chart I-9AUD Technicals 1 Chart I-10AUD Technicals 2 Recent data from Australia have been improving: CPI went up a notch in the fourth quarter, to 0.9% from 0.7%. The weighted median number was more encouraging at 1.4% NAB Business conditions improved from 9 to 14 in December. However, the expectations component deteriorated from 12 to 4. 4Q export prices rose by 5.5% quarter-on-quarter. The Australian dollar fell by 0.9% against the US dollar this week. The Aussie has been consolidating gains for most of January. The dominant feature driving the Aussie in the near term will continue to be terms of trade. We expect the AUD to resume its uptrend after a brief consolidation phase. We shied from implementing a short AUD/JPY trade today, preferring to express this view via short EUR/JPY. Report Links: An Update On The Australian Dollar - September 18, 2020 On AUD And CNY - January 17, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 New Zealand Dollar Chart I-11NZD Technicals 1 Chart I-12NZD Technicals 2 There was scant data out of New Zealand this week: The trade surplus in 2020 was NZ$2.9bn, compared to a deficit of NZ$4.5bn in 2019. The New Zealand dollar fell by 0.4% against the US dollar this week. Agricultural prices are consolidating after a rebounding from the lows of last year. Poor weather continues to be a worry on the supply side, but this is already reflected in very long Ag positioning. More should continue to deflate air off the high-flying kiwi. Report Links: Currencies And The Value-Versus-Growth Debate - July 10, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Place A Limit Sell On DXY At 100 - November 15, 2019 Canadian Dollar Chart I-13CAD Technicals 1 Chart I-14CAD Technicals 2 Recent data from Canada continues to disappoint: Building permits fell by 4.1% month-on-month in December. The Canadian dollar plunged by 1.3% against the US dollar this week. Oil prices are consolidating this year’s gains, which has weighed on the loonie. There is also the issue of the cancelled keystone XL pipeline, which is adding a risk premium for Canadian crude. We are short CAD/NOK as a trade, to capitalize on the latter headwind. Report Links: Currencies And The Value-Versus-Growth Debate - July 10, 2020 More On Competitive Devaluations, The CAD And The SEK - May 1, 2020 A New Paradigm For Petrocurrencies - April 10, 2020 Swiss Franc Chart I-15CHF Technicals 1 Chart I-16CHF Technicals 2 There was scant data out of Switzerland this week: The Swiss franc fell by 0.3% against the US dollar this week. The Swiss national bank (SNB) has two headaches to contend with in the coming weeks: a potential correction in the euro, which encourages safe-haven flows into the franc, and the lagged effects on a strong currency on domestic prices. This will force the hand of the SNB to continue being foreign exchange reserves at an aggressive pace. Report Links: The Dollar Conundrum And Protection - November 6, 2020 On The DXY Breakout, Euro, And Swiss Franc - February 21, 2020 Currency Market Signals From Gold, Equities And Flows - January 31, 2020 Norwegian Krone Chart I-17NOK Technicals 1 Chart I-18NOK Technicals 2 The data out of Norway has been robust: The unemployment rate came down in November to 5% from 5.2%. The Norwegian krone fell by 2% this week on oil-related losses. Despite this, good management of the COVID-19 situation remains a positive catalyst relative to US or European peers. We expect the krone to keep outperforming for the rest of the year. Report Links: Revisiting Our High-Conviction Trades - September 11, 2020 A New Paradigm For Petrocurrencies - April 10, 2020 Building A Protector Currency Portfolio - February 7, 2020 Swedish Krona Chart I-19SEK Technicals 1 Chart I-20SEK Technicals 2 Recent data from Sweden has been mixed: The unemployment rate ticked up in December from 8.3% to 8.7%. Retail sales fell by 0.6% year-on-year in December, after rising by 5.7% the previous month. The trade balance improved from SEK1.4bn to SEK2.7bn in December. The Swedish krona fell by 0.8% against the US dollar this week. As a high beta currency, the Swedish krona typically bears the brunt of a US dollar rally. However, this time around, valuations provide a sufficient margin of safety for investors that are long. Report Links: Revisiting Our High-Conviction Trades - September 11, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Where To Next For The US Dollar? - June 7, 2019 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Limit Orders Closed Trades
Dear client, In lieu of our regular report next Friday, we will be sending you a special report on Australia next Tuesday, co-authored with our Global Fixed Income colleagues. We hope you will find the report insightful. Kind regards, Chester Highlights Any tactical bounce in the dollar should be limited to 2-4%. A barbell strategy is the most attractive positioning in the next one to three months: a basket of the cheapest currencies and some safe havens. Remain short the gold/silver ratio. Feature Chart I-1Dollar Downside Hits Q1 Forecasts The market narrative towards the dollar is turning more bullish. Fundamental analysts point to the recent rise in US interest rates, relative to countries like Germany or the United Kingdom, as a serious cause for concern. A rules-based technical approach certainly warned that the dollar was getting much oversold last year, and the recent bounce is reinvigorating the possibility of a more powerful countertrend move. Being in the dollar-bearish camp, the key question is: how large could a potential dollar bounce be, and for how long can it last? According to Bloomberg forecasters, the dollar has already exhausted any potential decline penciled in for the first quarter of this year. Q1 consensus forecasts for the DXY index sit at 90, exactly where the index level rests today (Chart I-1). Bloomberg has consistently lowballed the level of the dollar since 2018, making the current forecast unduly bullish. This dovetails with recent market commentary that the decline in the dollar is largely done, and powerful catalysts for a countertrend move could take hold. Risks From The Reflation Trade Chart I-2A Stock Market Rout Could Derail The Dollar An equity market correction could be one of the potential catalysts that pushes the dollar higher. We showed last week that the dollar and the S&P 500 have had a near-perfect inverse correlation (Chart I-2). When a stock market and its currency exhibit an inverse correlation, it means that foreign investors have been hedging their equity purchases by selling the currency forward. This is not usually the norm (equity relative performance and currencies tend to move together), but was especially the case last year as inflows into US equities surged, but the dollar declined. Should any profit taking ensue, this will trigger a knee-jerk rally in the dollar, as forward shorts are closed. A few equity indicators warn that we could be at the cusp of such a counter-trend move: The put/call ratio in the US is extremely depressed. This warns that positioning is lopsided and could easily topple the equity market rally. A rising put / call ratio has been synonymous with a higher dollar over the past few years (Chart I-3). This will be consistent with foreign investors unwinding their dollar hedges (as they take profits on equities) and/or safe-haven inflows into the dollar. Chart I-3Both Puts And The Dollar Offer Protection Cyclical stocks continue to outperform defensive ones of late, but the cracks are beginning to emerge, specifically in the industrials space. Industrials share prices have been relapsing of late (Chart I-4). The dollar tends to weaken when cyclical stocks are outperforming defensive ones, and vice versa. This is because non-US equity markets have a much higher concentration of cyclical stocks in their bourses. The huge correction in the relative performance of the global tech sector also warns that the tech-heavy US bourse might benefit from any bounce in tech equities. Global earnings revisions are heading higher, but the momentum of US earnings has regained the upper hand, especially relative to the euro area. Bottom-up analysts are usually too optimistic about the level of earnings, but are generally spot on about their direction. Relative earnings revisions between the US and other markets have led the dollar by about nine to 12 months (Chart I-5). Should cyclical earnings hit a soft patch as the pandemic engulfs much of the developing world, the more defensive US market might prove resilient. Chart I-4A Red Flag From Global Industrials Chart I-5Earnings Revisions And The Dollar In a nutshell, corrections in equity markets are usually a healthy reset for the bull market to resume. In similar fashion, a washing out of stale US dollar short positions will ensure the bear market for 2021 unfolds with higher conviction. A garden-variety 5-10% cyclical correction in the S&P 500 has usually coincided with a 2-4% bounce in the DXY, as can be seen from Chart I-2. This could be the story over the next one to three months. The Signal From Currency Markets Our dollar capitulation index hit a nadir in July last year and has since been rebounding from very oversold levels. It has been very rare that a drop in this index below the 1.5 level did not trigger a rebound in the dollar (Chart I-6). Part of the reason this did not happen this time around has been concentration. Dollar short positions since 2020 have mostly been against the euro, yen and Swiss franc, with positioning in currencies such as the Australian dollar and Mexican peso more neutral. This will limit the extent to which the broad dollar index could rise from a flushing out of stale shorts. Chart I-6BCA Dollar Capitulation Index Suggests Some Upside For example, the exchange rate that best signals whether we are in a reflationary/deflationary environment is the AUD/JPY rate. Since the Great Recession, the yen has been the best performer during equity drawdowns, while the Aussie has been the worst. As a result, the AUD/JPY cross has consistently tracked the drawdown of the broad equity market (Chart I-7). As the bottom panel shows, exuberance in the AUD/JPY cross has also coincided with equity market peaks. That exuberance hardly exists today. The AUD/JPY cross has consistently tracked the drawdown of the broad equity market. That said, speculators are very short the dollar, even if the currencies used to implement these views are very concentrated. Sentiment towards the dollar is the lowest in over a decade and our intermediate-term indicator is at bombed-out levels (Chart I-8). Chart I-7AUD/JPY As A Risk On Gauge Chart I-8The Dollar Is Oversold In a nutshell, the message from technical indicators is that a bounce in the dollar is to be expected. However, the magnitude will be smaller than prior episodes. Ever since the dollar peaked in March 2020, counter-trend moves have been in the order of 2-3%. We expect this time to be no different. The Dollar And Commodities Commodity prices across the board have been on a tear. This has usually been an environment where the dollar is in a broad-based decline. Commodity prices hold a special place as FX market indicators, since they are both driven by final demand and financial speculation. More importantly, rising commodity demand can signal an improving FX trend between commodity producing (Australia, Canada, Mexico, Colombia, Russia) and importing (Euro area, India, Turkey, or even China) countries. We will buy the currencies of commodity producers on weakness as the bull market continues. Metals prices have exploded higher on strong demand, especially from China (Chart I-9). Not surprisingly, speculative positioning in copper options and futures is also extremely elevated. If investors have been betting on higher copper prices, based on the expectation of a lower dollar, then a relapse in the red metal will be synonymous with a higher greenback. That said, commodity bull markets have tended to last over a decade, with the recent rise in prices also driven by deficient supply. As such, we will buy the currencies of commodity producers on weakness, rather than sell on strength, as the bull market continues. This also argues for a fleeting technical bounce in the dollar. Chart I-9A Bull Market In Metals Chart I-10The Gold/Silver Ratio is Rebounding Within the commodity space, watching the gold/silver ratio (GSR) is instructive. The GSR tends to track the US dollar (Chart I-10). This is because it has usually rallied on safe-haven demand and relapsed once there is a pickup in economic (or manufacturing) activity. Gold benefits from plentiful liquidity and very low real rates, while silver benefits from rising industrial demand. It is possible the surge in global infections dampens economic activity and lifts demand for safe havens. This will be good for the dollar. However, as vaccinations take hold and the economy reopens, silver will surge. Relative Interest Rates Interest rates are moving in favor of the dollar, and there has been a long-standing relationship between relative real rates and the US currency. The question is whether the rise in US interest rates has been sufficient to compensate investors for the higher budget deficits they will need to finance. To answer this, it is always instructive to look at the relationship between gold and US Treasuries. Remarkably, the ratio of the total return in US government bonds-to-gold prices has tracked the dollar pretty well since the end of the Bretton Woods system in the early 1970s. The bond-to-gold ratio is an important signal for the dollar, since both US Treasuries and gold are safe-haven assets and thus, by definition, are competing assets (Chart I-11). The ratio of the US bond ETF (TLT)-to-gold (GLD) is an important proxy for investor sentiment on the dollar (Chart I-12). Ultimately, investors are driven by real rates. Positive real returns will favor Treasuries, while negative real returns will favor gold. The latter appears to have the upper hand for now. Remarkably, the ratio of the total return in US government bonds-to-gold prices has tracked the dollar pretty well since the end of the Bretton Woods system in the early 1970s. Chart I-11Gold and Treasurys Are Competing Assets Chart I-12Watch The Bond-To-Gold Ratio The implication is that the rise in US interest rates has not yet convinced investors that a significant margin of safety exists for possible runaway inflation. This augurs badly for the dollar, beyond the near term. Investment Implications Our investment strategy is simple: hold a basket of the cheapest currencies and, some safe havens that will benefit if the dollar bounces. Opportunities at the crosses also make sense. On safe-haven currencies, our preferred vehicle is the Japanese yen, which sports an attractive real rate relative to the US. Relative value is particularly attractive on short CAD/NOK, long AUD/NZD, short EUR/GBP and long EUR/CHF. Stick with them. Stay short USD/JPY and long the Scandinavian currencies as a core holding. Remain short the gold/silver ratio. Chester Ntonifor Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1 Chart II-2USD Technicals 2 Recent data in the US have been resilient: The headline 140K job loss last Friday was not as dire, looking into the details. There was a net two-month revision of +135K jobs. Core CPI came in line at 1.6% year-on-year, while average weekly earnings surged by 4.9%. MBA mortgage applications came in at a blockbuster 16.7% week-on-week, for the week ending on January 8. The DXY rose by 0.3% this week. There was some element of consolidation in markets earlier this week, with a few equity bourses softening and the dollar catching a bid. However, that has been overwhelmed by the reflation trade as we go to press. We expect any dollar bounce to be technical in nature, and in order of magnitude of around 2-4%. Report Links: The Dollar In A Blue Wave - January 8, 2021 The Dollar Conundrum And Protection - November 6, 2020 The Dollar In A Market Reset - October 30, 2020 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1 Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2 Recent data from the euro area have help up: The unemployment rate in the euro area fell from 8.4% to 8.3% in November. Sentix investor confidence remains resilient at 1.3 in January, versus -2.7 the previous month. Industrial production in the euro area is recovering, as signaled by the PMI releases. The euro fell by 0.5% against the US dollar this week. The unfolding political crisis in Italy warns that the euro might be due for a setback, as European peripheral bond spreads rise. We remain bullish the euro longer-term, but short-term trades are at risk from lopsided positioning. Report Links: The Dollar Conundrum And Protection - November 6, 2020 Addressing Client Questions - September 4, 2020 On The DXY Breakout, Euro, And Swiss Franc - February 21, 2020 The Japanese Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1 Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2 Recent data from Japan has been better than expected: The expectations component of the Eco Watchers Survey rose from 36.5 to 37.1, versus expectations of 30.5 in December. Machine tool orders continued to inflect higher in December, to the tune of 8.7% year-on-year. Bank lending remained around a robust 6% in December. The Japanese yen was flat against the US dollar this week. Japanese fixed income investors are in a quagmire, since nominal rates are better in the US, but real rates are more favorable in Japan. The yen could remain caught in a tug of war between these forces, with a slight advantage to Japanese rates. We remain long the yen as a portfolio hedge. Report Links: The Dollar Conundrum And Protection - November 6, 2020 The Near-Term Bull Case For The Dollar - February 28, 2020 Building A Protector Currency Portfolio - February 7, 2020 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1 Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2 There was scant data out of the UK this week: BRC like-for-like sales rose by 4.8% year-on-year in December. The British pound rose by 0.8% against the US dollar this week. Vaccinations continue to progress smoothly in the UK, but cracks are already starting to emerge in the post Brexit UK-EU relationship. There are mounting food shortages in Northern Ireland and a hiccup in fish exports from the UK, as the necessary paperwork adds a layer of bureaucracy. As investors digest the potential impact to the pound, it will add to volatility. Ultimately, a cheap pound should outperform both the dollar and euro. Report Links: The Dollar Conundrum And Protection - November 6, 2020 Revisiting Our High-Conviction Trades - September 11, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1 Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2 There was little data out of Australia this week: The final retail sales print was 7.1% month-on-month in November. The Australian dollar appreciated by 0.4% against the US dollar this week. Base metals, especially copper and iron ore have been on a tear this year. This is boosting Australian terms of trade. More importantly, a shortage of ships has catapulted Asian LNG prices to all-time highs as a cold spell hits countries like Japan and Korea. This should be beneficial for Australian energy producers. We are currently long AUD/NZD. Report Links: An Update On The Australian Dollar - September 18, 2020 On AUD And CNY - January 17, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1 Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2 There was scant data out of New Zealand this week: REINZ house sales rose by 36.6% year-on-year in December. Building permits rose 1.2% month-on-month in November. The New Zealand dollar fell by 0.3% against the US dollar this week. The release of the US WASDE report confirmed a looming agricultural shortage, as production forecasts were slashed on weather worries. This is NZD bullish. That said, technically, agricultural prices are stretched, and so some consolidation will deflate air off the high-flying kiwi. In a commodity basket, we prefer the Aussie that is underpinned by more structural factors. Report Links: Currencies And The Value-Versus-Growth Debate - July 10, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Place A Limit Sell On DXY At 100 - November 15, 2019 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1 Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2 Recent data from Canada have been disappointing: Employment fell by 62.6K jobs in December. However, this was driven by 99K part-time job losses, with full-time job gains of 36.5K. The sales outlook in the BoC survey improved from 39 to 48 in 4Q 2020. The Canadian dollar appreciated by 0.5% against the US dollar this week. Oil prices are dominating commodity gains this year, given the shift from Saudi Arabia and the prospect of higher transport demand. This bodes well for the loonie. Report Links: Currencies And The Value-Versus-Growth Debate - July 10, 2020 More On Competitive Devaluations, The CAD And The SEK - May 1, 2020 A New Paradigm For Petrocurrencies - April 10, 2020 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1 Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2 Recent data from Switzerland have been mixed: The unemployment rate was flat at 3.4% in December. FX reserves increased from CHF 876 billion to CHF 891 billion. The Swiss franc fell by 0.2% against the US dollar this week. The biggest risk to Switzerland and the SNB authorities is a potential correction in the euro, which encourages safe-haven flows into the franc. This will also be a risk to our long EUR/CHF position. Our bias is that the valuation cushion on the cross provides an ample margin of safety. Report Links: The Dollar Conundrum And Protection - November 6, 2020 On The DXY Breakout, Euro, And Swiss Franc - February 21, 2020 Currency Market Signals From Gold, Equities And Flows - January 31, 2020 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1 Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2 The data out of Norway has been robust: Headline CPI came in at 1.4% year-on-year, while underlying CPI was a whopping 3%. House prices rose 2.9% quarter-on-quarter in Q4. Industrial production came in at -0.9% in November, an improvement from -2.7% the previous month. The Norwegian krone is the best performing currency this year at +1.5%. Good management of the COVID-19 situation as well as rising oil prices have been positive catalysts. We expect the krone to keep outperforming for the rest of the year. Report Links: Revisiting Our High-Conviction Trades - September 11, 2020 A New Paradigm For Petrocurrencies - April 10, 2020 Building A Protector Currency Portfolio - February 7, 2020 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1 Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2 Recent data from Sweden has been rather disappointing: Private sector production fell by 1% year-on-year in November. We would expect this to reverse with the improvement in the December PMIs. Industrial orders rose 5.7% year-on-year in November. Household consumption fell 5% year-on-year in November. The Swedish krona has been the worst performing currency this year, falling by 0.7% against the US dollar this week. That said, it might be a case of profit taking. The Swedish krona remains cheap and should benefit from an upshot in the global manufacturing cycle. Report Links: Revisiting Our High-Conviction Trades - September 11, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Where To Next For The US Dollar? - June 7, 2019 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Limit Orders Closed Trades
Highlights Our base case of a Biden win with a GOP Senate may come to pass. But the US election is not over yet. Trump still has a chance of victory by winning Pennsylvania and one other state. If the vote count does not settle the outcome clearly this week, a full-fledged contested election will emerge that may not be settled until just before December 14 (or even January). Risk-off sentiment will prevail in the interim, given the importance of the executive-legislative configuration for the pandemic response and the fiscal policy outlook. What we know is that Republicans kept the Senate, in line with our final forecast last week. This means gridlock is assured – which is positive for US stocks beyond near-term fiscal risks. Stay long JPY-USD, short CNY-USD, long stocks over bonds, long health care equipment, and long infrastructure plays. Keep dry powder for the presidential outcome, as global trade hangs in the balance. Feature The US presidential election is unsettled as we go to press, but we know that Republicans will keep control of the Senate and hence that American government will be divided or “gridlocked” for the next two years. As things stand, Democrats picked up two senate seats, Arizona and Colorado, but fell short everywhere else. They may even have lost a seat in Michigan. This leaves the balance of power at ~52-48 in favor of Republicans – which is one seat better than our final 51-49 forecast in their favor (Chart 1).1 Chart 1Our Senate Election Model Correctly Predicted Republican Control Table 1Gridlock Is Inevitable Regardless Of Presidential Outcome Gridlock is the inevitable consequence. If President Trump pulls off a victory in any two of the upper Midwestern states (Michigan, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin), then he will still face a Democrat-controlled House of Representatives. If former Vice President Joe Biden pulls off a victory in two of these states, then he will face a Republican controlled Senate (Table 1). Chart 2Gridlock More Favorable Than Sweep For Wall Street, But Fiscal Risks Abound In Short Run Historically gridlock offers more upside for the S&P 500 than a single-party sweep (Chart 2), and we agree with this expectation when it comes to the long-run impact of this election. However, we have also warned against the fiscal risks of a Biden win with a Republican Senate in the short run. The status quo Trump gridlock is reflationary at first but later problematic due to trade war. The Biden gridlock is deflationary at first but the best outcome for investors over the long run. Consider the following: Trump with Senate Republicans: Trump is a spendthrift and he and his party joined the House Democrats in blowing out the budget deficit from 2018-20. Trump’s victory will force House Speaker Nancy Pelosi to concede to a Republican-drafted ~$1-$1.5 trillion new COVID-19 fiscal relief bill right away. For the second term, Trump will push an infrastructure bill, border security, and make his tax cuts permanent. The fiscal thrust in 2021 will be flat-to-up. The budget deficit will probably end up somewhere between the Republican “high spending” scenario and the Democratic “low spending” scenario in our budget deficit projections (Chart 3). This is positive for US growth and especially corporate earnings, but it comes with a catch: Trump will be emboldened in his trade wars, which could expand beyond China to Europe or others. Tariffs and currency depreciation will weigh on global growth. Still, Trump’s second term will occur in the early stages of the business cycle and the Fed is committed not to hike rates until 2023, so the overall picture is reflationary. Chart 3Trump Gridlock Reflationary, Biden Gridlock Deflationary Over Short Run Biden with Senate Republicans: Since Senate Republicans did not capitulate to large Democratic spending demands prior to the election, when their seats were at risk, they will have less incentive to do so afterwards when the president hails from the opposing party. The only way they will agree to a new fiscal stimulus in the “lame duck” session (November-December) is if the Democrats concede to their skinny proposals for the time being. But Democrats will probably insist on their demands having made electoral gains. In this case, either financial markets will sell off, forcing Republicans to capitulate, or investors will have to wait until early 2021 to receive a new fiscal bill that is uncertain in size and timing. The first battle of Biden’s presidency will be with the GOP Senate. The Republican “low spending” scenario in Chart 3 is most likely. It is not realistic that Congress will allow the baseline scenario, in which the budget deficit contracts by ~7.4% of GDP. Republican senators today are not the Tea Party House Republicans of 2010, who were rabid fiscal hawks. Still, uncertainty will weigh heavily and markets will have to fall before GOP senators wake up to the underlying risk to the economic recovery. The consolation is that beyond this 3-6 month period of negative sentiment and deflationary fiscal risk, the outlook will be fairly positive. Biden will not use broad-based unilateral tariffs the way Trump did, with the possible exception of China later in his term. And the Republican Senate will not agree to tax hikes at any point, making taxes a concern for 2023 or thereafter. This is the best of both worlds for US business sentiment and the corporate earnings outlook over the two-year period. Risk-off sentiment will prevail until the election is decided. This could be in a couple of days if the vote count is clear in Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin. Or it could extend until just before December 14, when the Electoral College votes, if the litigation and court rulings in these critical states drag on, which we discuss below. The reason risk-off sentiment will prevail is that the US economy is burning through its remaining stimulus funds rapidly, the fiscal trajectory is unclear until the presidency is decided, Europe is going into partial lockdowns over the pandemic, and a Biden victory would imply more US lockdowns. Diagram 1 outlines the macro and market implications as we see them, depending on the presidential outcome. We never took the view that a Democratic sweep of White House and Senate would be the best outcome for the overall investment outlook, though we conceded that it was the most reflationary and bullish in the short term. But now this point is moot. Investors will have to wait another two years at minimum for the full smorgasbord of Democratic spending proposals to have a chance at passage. Diagram 1Gridlock Rules Out Massive Fiscal Boost Bottom Line: The presidency is indeterminate as we go to press. What is clear is that Republicans retained the Senate. Therefore gridlock will prevail. This is generally market positive, though a Biden win would weigh on risk assets in the near term until financial markets force Republican senators to capitulate to a new fiscal bill. A Controversial Election Or A Contested Election? The critical battleground states are undecided as we go to press. Trump needs to win any two of Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin to retain the White House. The vote count will last through Wednesday and possibly beyond. The Republican and Democratic legal teams are preparing for trench warfare. Major legal challenges are highly likely and will delay the final outcome into December or even January. The first thing is to finish counting the absentee and mail-in ballots. Georgia, Michigan, Wisconsin, and Arizona are not accepting ballots after election day, so they will finish counting soon. Then all that remains is to see if any legal disputes arise that prevent the Electoral College members from being settled in these states, which is still possible. For example, Wisconsin is within a percentage point. Nevada will accept ballots by November 10 and North Carolina by November 12 as long as they are postmarked by election day. It is likely but not certain that Democrats will keep Nevada (~75% counted) while Republicans will keep North Carolina (~100% counted). Thus Pennsylvania poses the biggest risk of a contested result – and this was anticipated. The deadline to receive mailed ballots is Friday, November 6, but a legal dispute is already underway as to whether the original November 3 deadline should be reinstated.2 We will not pretend to predict the final court verdict on Pennsylvania, but it would not be surprising at all if the Supreme Court ruled that ballots received after election day cannot be accepted. The constitution grants state legislatures the sole power of choosing a state’s electors. Each state passes its own election laws. The Pennsylvania state legislature clearly stated that ballots must be returned by election day. It was a court decision that extended the deadline. The Supreme Court could easily determine that a lower court does not have the power to change the deadline. But nobody will know until the court rules. The fact that Trump appointed several of the judges has little bearing on their decisions because they serve lifetime appointments. Once election disputes rise above state vote-counting to the federal level, Trump gets a lifeline. First, the two-seat conservative leaning on the Supreme Court should produce strict readings of the law that could favor his bid. Second, the GOP’s victory in the Senate means that Democrats cannot unilaterally settle disputed electoral votes in their own favor at the joint session of Congress on January 6, which they could have done with a united Congress. Third, the Republicans are likely to have maintained a one or two-state majority of state delegations in the House of Representatives (based on results as we go to press), which means that Trump would win if the candidates failed to reach a 270-vote majority on the Electoral College or tied at 269. Note that an Electoral College tie is a distinct possibility in this election. Right now, if Trump loses in Michigan and Wisconsin, but wins Pennsylvania, and nothing else changes, then an Electoral College tie could result at 269-269 electoral votes.3 Polls … And Exit Polls Before condemning the entire profession of opinion pollsters to death it will be important to receive the verified results of the election and compare them with the final polling averages. It is clear that Trump was widely underrated yet again, but it is not yet clear that this was primarily or exclusively the fault of pollsters. Right now Trump is down by 1.8% in the nationwide popular vote, whereas he lagged by 7.2% in the average of the national polls and 2.3% in the battleground average on election day. This is a big 5.4% gap in the national poll, but in the battleground poll it is a minor 0.5% polling gap and as such merely confirms what many observers knew, that the battleground polls were the ones that really mattered due to the Electoral College. Trump’s battleground support average was 46.6% and his approval rating was 45.9% on election day, which respectively is 1.8% and 2.5% below his tentative share of the national vote at 48.4%. These gaps are within the average 3% margin of error – and normally sitting presidents outperform their polling by around 1%. State opinion polling had huge errors like the national poll. Charts 4 and 4B shows the final election polling in the critical swing states along with a “T” or “B” to mark Trump’s and Biden’s tentative vote share as we go to press. Swing state polls showed Trump staging a major rally in the final weeks of the campaign, which is what prompted us to upgrade his odds to 45%. Neither major pundits nor the mainstream media paid enough attention to this shift. Several prominent outlets denied that there was any real tightening in the polls even in late October. Chart 4APundits Overlooked Trump’s Rally In Swing State Polls In Final Weeks Chart 4BPundits Overlooked Trump’s Rally In Swing State Polls In Final Weeks What this demonstrates to us is the power of momentum in opinion polling, especially in the final week before an election when people’s attitudes harden and they bare more of their true opinions. It does not tell us that opinion polling is dead. What about the exit polls? Biden cut into Trump’s lead in key demographic groups just as the Democratic Party machinery anticipated, but it is not clear if it was enough to win the election. Trump lost ground and Democrats gained ground, relative to 2016, with white voters, old folks, and non-college-educated voters. But Trump improved his support among blacks and Hispanics, a signal point that gives the lie to much of this year’s media hype (Charts 5A and 5B). Chart 5ADemocrats Gained Ground With White, Elderly, And Non-College-Educated Voters; GOP Gained Among Blacks And Hispanics Chart 5BDemocrats Gained Ground With White, Elderly, And Non-College-Educated Voters; GOP Gained Among Blacks And Hispanics By far voters cared most about the issues, not personalities, and the biggest issue was the economy (35% of voters versus 20% on racial inequality and 17% on the coronavirus, which was apparently overrated as an issue by Democrats). The economic focus is the only explanation for Trump’s outperformance – the law and order narrative was less popular. Trump’s vote share may end up exactly equal to the number of respondents who said the economy was “good” or “excellent” (48%). Otherwise Trump’s base is well known: it consists predominantly of white people, rural people, those in the Midwest and South, those who have been fairly successful in income, and those who think America needs a “strong leader” more than a unifier with good judgment who seems to care about the average person. If Trump is defeated, the clear implication is that he failed to expand his base. If he wins, the clear implication is that Democrats suffered in the key regions for their aggressive approach to COVID lockdowns, their condoning of lawlessness, and their divisive handling of racial inequality and police brutality. With such a close vote for the White House, sweeping narratives are questionable. It is not clear yet whether liberalism or nationalism won, and at any rate the margin was thin. What is clear is that Democrats substantially disappointed in the Senate and they might even have failed to gain the White House. Given that this year witnessed a recession, pandemic, and widespread social unrest – well-attested historical signs that point to the failure of the incumbent party and recession – Democrats apparently failed to capitalize. National exit polls suggest the fault lay in their relative neglect of bread and butter in favor of the coronavirus or left-wing social theory. This is true not so much in the House of Representatives but in the presidential and senate races. If Trump wins – especially through a contested election – then US political polarization will rise due to the continued divergence of popular opinion and the constitutional system. “Peak polarization” will last another four years at least. But if Trump loses, given that Republicans held the Senate, there is room for compromise that would reduce polarization. But it is too early to say. Investment Takeaways Trade and foreign policy hinge on the presidency. Trump is favored in several of the key states at the moment and he is especially favored in a contested election process, but it is too soon to make investment recommendations on the executive branch other than that US equity outperformance is likely to continue on both of the scenarios at hand. Table 2Earnings Shock From Partial Repeal Of Trump Tax Cuts Has Been Averted For now we recommend investors stay long JPY-USD, short CNY-USD, long health care equipment, and overweight stocks relative to bonds. On the Senate, the key takeaway is that Biden and the Democrats will not be able to raise taxes. This is a big benefit to the sectors that faced the greatest earnings shock from a partial repeal of Trump’s Tax Cuts and Jobs Act – namely real estate, tech, health care, utilities, consumer discretionary, and financials (Table 2). A simple play on these sectoral benefits courtesy of Anastasios Avgeriou, our US equity strategist, would be to go long small caps versus large caps, i.e. S&P 600 relative to the S&P 500, but wait till the fiscal hurdle is cleared. The BCA infrastructure basket should benefit regardless, as infrastructure is one of the few areas of bipartisan agreement, especially amid a large output gap. Matt Gertken Vice President Geopolitical Strategy mattg@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 We upgraded the Republicans to favored status last week based on our quantitative Senate election model, which showed a 51% chance that Republicans would maintain control, with 51-49 votes. Our presidential model also showed Trump winning with a 51% chance, but we subjectively capped his odds at 45% due to our doubts about his ability to win Michigan given Biden’s 4% lead in head-to-head public opinion polls there. 2 It is possible that Nevada’s November 10 deadline or North Carolina’s November 12 deadline could become relevant, but we doubt it. 3 Precise Electoral College outcomes cannot be predicted due to faithless electors, i.e. electoral college members who vote differently than required based on their state’s popular vote. In 2016 there were seven faithless electors and in 2020 there could be several and they could make the difference. Material punishments may not prevent an elector from making a conscientious decision to stray from his or her state’s results in an election viewed as having historic importance.
Highlights Historically, when global growth picks up, the yen weakens. But this is less likely in an environment where global yields remain anchored at low levels. Meanwhile, there is rising risk that consumption in Japan will remain muted. This will limit any pickup in domestic inflation. A modest rise in real rates will lead to a self-reinforcing upward spiral for the yen. That said, cheap yen valuations will buffet Japanese exports. Go short USD/JPY with an initial target of 100. Feature Chart I-1Higher Volatility, Higher Yen The powerful bounce in global markets since the March lows is at risk of a bigger technical correction. As we enter the volatile summer months, it may only require a small shift in market sentiment to trigger this reversal. The yen has tended to strengthen when market volatility rises (Chart I-1). Should this happen, it will provide the necessary catalyst for established long yen positions. On the other hand, if risk sentiment stays ebullient, the yen will surely weaken on its crosses but can still strengthen vis-à-vis the dollar. This places short USD/JPY bets in an enviable “heads I win, tails I do not lose too much” position. Growth And Monetary Policy Like most other economies, Japan entered a recession in the first quarter of this year, with GDP contracting at a 2.2% annualized pace. For the private sector, this is the worst growth rate since the Fukushima crisis in 2011. This is particularly significant, since the structural growth rate of the economy has fallen below interest rates. Going back to Japan’s lost decades, where private sector GDP growth averaged well below nominal rates (due to the zero bound), it is particularly imperative that Japan exits this liquidity trap in fast order (Chart I-2). A strong yen back then, on the back of deficient domestic demand, led to a self-fulfilling deflationary spiral. Chart I-2The Story Of Japan In One Chart The Bank of Japan began to acknowledge this problem with the end of the Heisei era1 last year. For example, with the BoJ owning almost 50% of outstanding JGBs, the supply side puts a serious limitation on how much more stimulus the BoJ can provide. The yen has become extremely sensitive to shifts in the relative balance sheets between the Federal Reserve and the BoJ. If the BoJ continues to purchase securities at the current pace, then the rate of expansion in its balance sheet will severely lag behind the Fed, and could trigger a knee-jerk rally in the yen (Chart I-3). Chart I-3The Yen And QE Inflation And The 2% Target The US is a much more closed economy than Japan, and has not been able to maintain a 2% inflation rate since the Global Financial Crisis. This makes the BoJ’s target of 2% a pipe dream for any timeline in the near future. There are three key variables the authorities pay attention to for inflation: Core CPI, the GDP deflator and the output gap. All three indicators point towards deflationary pressures, with the recent slowdown in the global economy exacerbating the trend. In fact, since the financial crisis, prices in Japan have only been able to really rise during a tax hike (Chart I-4). Always forgotten is that the overarching theme for prices in Japan is a rapidly falling (and ageing) population, leading to deficient demand. The overarching theme for prices in Japan is a rapidly falling (and ageing) population, leading to deficient demand. More importantly, almost 50% of the Japanese consumption basket is in tradeable goods, meaning domestic inflation is as much driven by the influence of the BoJ as it is by globalization. Even for domestically-driven prices, an ageing demographic that has a strong preference for falling prices is a powerful conflicting force. For example, over the years, a strong voting lobby has been able to advocate for lower telecom prices, which makes it difficult for the BoJ to re-anchor inflation expectations upward (Chart I-5). Chart I-4Japan CPI At A Glance Chart I-5Strong Deflationary Pressures In Japan Meanwhile, the BoJ understands that it needs domestic banks to expand the credit intermediation process if any inflation is to take hold. Unfortunately, the yield curve control strategy and negative interest rates have been anathema for Japanese net interest margins and share prices (Chart I-6). This puts the BoJ in a precarious balance between trying to stimulate the economy further and biting the hand that will feed a pickup in inflation. Chart I-6Point Of No Return For Japanese Banks? Japanese Consumption And Fiscal Policy The consumption tax hike last year delivered a severe punch to aggregate demand in Japan. COVID-19 has dealt a fatal blow. In prior episodes of the tax hikes, it took around three to four quarters for growth to eventually bottom. This suggests that a protracted slowdown in Japanese consumption is a fait accompli (Chart I-7). Foreign and domestic machinery orders are slowing, employment growth has gone from over 2% to free fall and the availability of jobs relative to applicants has reversed a decade-long rising trend. The Abe government has passed an additional 117 trillion yen of fiscal stimulus. With overall fiscal announcements near 40% of GDP, could this fully plug the spending gap? Not quite. The consumption tax hike last year delivered a severe punch to aggregate demand in Japan. First, as is usually the case with Japanese stimulus announcements, the timeframe is uncertain for when the funds will be deployed. It could be one year or ten years. Chart I-7A V-Shaped Recovery Might Stall Chart I-8More Jobs, More Savings Second, Japanese consumption has been quite weak for some time. Despite relatively robust economic conditions since the Fukushima disaster, Japanese consumption has trended downward. The reason is that government spending triggered a rise in private savings, because of expectations of higher taxes. In other words, the savings ratio for workers has surged. If consumers were not willing to spend prior to COVID-19 due to Ricardian equivalence,2 they are unlikely to do so with much higher fiscal deficits (Chart I-8). Some of the government’s outlays will certainly go a long way to boosting aggregate demand, since the fiscal multiplier tends to be much larger in a liquidity trap. This will especially be the case for increased social security spending such as child education, construction activity or the move towards promoting cashless transactions (with a tax rebate). However, there are important near-term offsets. In particular, the postponement of the Olympics will continue to be a drag on Japanese construction activity, and the labor (and income) dividend from immigration has practically vanished. The important tourism industry that faced sudden death will only recover slowly. This suggests a much more protracted recovery in many nuggets of Japanese activity. The Yen As A Safe Haven Real interest rates are already higher in Japan, well before any of the above factors began to meaningfully generate a deflationary impulse. As such, the starting point for yen long positions is already favorable (Chart I-9). Real interest rates are already higher in Japan, well before any of the above factors began to meaningfully generate a deflationary impulse. With global growth bottoming, a continued rise in global equity markets is a key risk to our scenario. However, if inflows into Japan accelerate on cheap equity valuations, the propensity of investors to hedge these purchases will be much less today, given how cheap the yen has become. This is especially important since in an era of rising budget deficits, balance of payments dynamics can resurface as the key driver of currencies. This suggests the negative yen/Nikkei correlation will continue to weaken, as has been the case in recent quarters. Chart I-9Real Rates And The Yen Chart I-10USD/JPY And DXY Are Positively Correlated As a low-beta currency, our contention is that the yen will surely weaken on its crosses, but could strengthen versus the dollar. The yen rises versus the dollar not only during recessions, but during most episodes of broad dollar weakness (Chart I-10). This places short USD/JPY trades in an envious “heads I win, tails I do not lose too much” position. Chester Ntonifor Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 The Heisei era refers to the period of Japanese history corresponding to the reign of Emperor Akihito from 8 January 8th, 1989 until his abdication on April 30th, 2019. 2 Ricardian equivalence suggests in simple terms that public sector dissaving will encourage private sector savings. Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1 Chart II-2USD Technicals 2 Recent data in the US have been robust: Nonfarm payrolls increased by 2.5 million in May after declining by a record 20.7 million in April. This was better than expectations of an 8 million job loss. The unemployment rate fell from 14.7% to 13.3%. The NFIB business optimism index increased from 90.9 to 94.4 in May. Headline consumer price inflation fell from 0.3% to 0.1% year-on-year in May. Core inflation fell from 1.4% to 1.2%. Initial jobless claims increased by 1542K for the week ended June 5th. The DXY index fell by 1.3% this week. On Wednesday, the Fed left interest rates unchanged, with a signal that rates might not be increased before the end of 2022. The Fed also stated that it will maintain the current pace of Treasuries and mortgage-backed securities purchases, at minimum. Report Links: DXY: False Breakdown Or Cyclical Bear Market? - June 5, 2020 Cycles And The US Dollar - May 15, 2020 Capitulation? - April 3, 2020 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1 Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2 Recent data in the euro area have been improving: The Sentix investor confidence index improved from -41.8 to -24.8 in June. Employment increased by 0.4% year-on-year in Q1. GDP contracted by 3.1% year-on-year in Q1. The euro appreciated by 1.2% against the US dollar this week. At an online seminar held this week, Isabel Schnabel, member of the executive board of the ECB, noted that "evidence is increasingly pointing towards a protracted impact of the crisis on both demand and supply conditions in the euro area and beyond" and that the current PEPP remains appropriate in de aling with the global recession. Report Links: On The DXY Breakout, Euro, And Swiss Franc - February 21, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 On Money Velocity, EUR/USD And Silver - October 11, 2019 Japanese Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1 Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2 Recent data in Japan have been negative: The coincident index fell from 88.8 to 81.5 in April. The leading economic index also decreased from 85.1 to 76.2. The current account surplus shrank from ¥1971 billion to ¥262.7 billion in April. Annualized GDP fell by 2.2% year-on-year in Q1. Machine tool orders plunged by 52.8% year-on-year in May, following a 48.3% decrease the previous month. The Japanese yen appreciated by 2.6% against the US dollar this week. According to a Bloomberg survey, the majority of economists believe that the BoJ has done enough to cushion the economy, and expect the BoJ to leave current monetary policy unchanged next week. We continue to recommend the yen as a safe-haven hedge, especially given a possible second wave of COVID-19. Report Links: The Near-Term Bull Case For The Dollar - February 28, 2020 Building A Protector Currency Portfolio - February 7, 2020 Currency Market Signals From Gold, Equities And Flows - January 31, 2020 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1 Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2 Recent data in the UK have been positive: Halifax house prices increased by 2.6% year-on-year in May. Retail sales surged by 7.9% year-on-year in May, up from 5.7% the previous month. GfK consumer confidence was little changed at -36 in May. The British pound rose by 1% against the US dollar this week. On Wednesday, BoE governor Andrew Bailey noted that easing lockdown restrictions has been fueling a recovery in the UK, which could be faster than previously anticipated. Our long GBP/USD and short EUR/GBP positions are 4% and 0.2% in the money, respectively. Report Links: Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 A Few Trade Ideas - Sept. 27, 2019 United Kingdom: Cyclical Slowdown Or Structural Malaise? - Sept. 20, 2019 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1 Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2 Recent data in Australia have been mixed: The NAB business confidence index increased from -45 to -20 in May. The business conditions index also ticked up from -34 to -24. The Westpac consumer confidence index increased from 88.1 to 93.7 in June. Home loans declined by 4.8% month-on-month in April, down from a 0.3% increase the previous month. That said, expectations were for a fall of 10%. AUD/USD was flat this week. While the RBA has other options in its policy toolkit to combat the global recession, negative interest rates is still on the table and hasn't been totally ruled out. We remain positive on the Australian dollar both against the US dollar and the New Zealand dollar due to cheap valuations and increasing Chinese stimulus. Report Links: On AUD And CNY - January 17, 2020 Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 A Contrarian View On The Australian Dollar - May 24, 2019 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1 Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2 Recent data in New Zealand have been mixed: Manufacturing sales declined by 1.7% quarter-on-quarter in Q1, down from a 2.8% increase the previous quarter. ANZ business confidence increased from -41.8 to -33 in June. The activity outlook index also ticked up from -38.7 to -29.1. The New Zealand dollar appreciated by 0.8% against the US dollar this week. RBNZ's Deputy Governor Geoff Bascand said that house prices in New Zealand could fall by 9-10% or even worse. Besides disrupting exports and imports for a trade-reliant country like New Zealand, the global health crisis is also likely to further reduce immigration to New Zealand, curbing housing demand. Report Links: Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Place A Limit Sell On DXY At 100 - November 15, 2019 USD/CNY And Market Turbulence - August 9, 2019 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1 Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2 Recent data in Canada have been positive: The unemployment rate ticked up from 13% to 13.7% in May, versus expectations of a rise to 15%, but this was due to a rise in the participation rate from 59.8% to 61.4%. Average hourly wages increased by 10% year-on-year in May. Net employment increased by 289.6K, up from a 1994K job loss the previous month. Housing starts increased by 193.5K in May, up from 166.5K the previous month. The Canadian dollar fell by 0.2% against the US dollar this week. The labor market has seen some recovery in May with the gradual easing of COVID-19 restrictions and re-opening of the economy. Employment rebounded and absences from work dropped. Notably, Quebec accounts for nearly 80% of overall employment gains in May. Report Links: More On Competitive Devaluations, The CAD And The SEK - May 1, 2020 A New Paradigm For Petrocurrencies - April 10, 2020 The Loonie: Upside Versus The Dollar, But Downside At The Crosses Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1 Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2 There was scant data out of Switzerland this week: FX reserves increased from CHF 801 billion to CHF 816 billion in May. The unemployment rate increased from 3.1% to 3.4% in May, lower than the expected 3.7%. The Swiss franc appreciated by 2.3% against the US dollar this week, reflecting a flight back to safety amid concerns over political risks and a second wave of COVID-19. While the euro has been strong recently and EUR/CHF touched 1.09, the franc has lost most of those gains. We are lifting our limit buy on EUR/CHF to 1.055 on expectations we are in a run-of-the-mill correction. Report Links: On The DXY Breakout, Euro, And Swiss Franc - February 21, 2020 Currency Market Signals From Gold, Equities And Flows - January 31, 2020 Portfolio Tweaks Before The Chinese New Year - January 24, 2020 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1 Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2 Recent data in Norway have been mixed: Manufacturing output shrank by 1.6% month-on-month in April. PPI fell by 17.5% year-on-year in May. Headline consumer prices increased by 1.3% year-on-year in May, up from 0.8% the previous month. Core inflation also increased from 2.8% to 3% in May. The Norwegian krone fell by 1.5% against the US dollar this week. The recent OPEC meeting over the weekend concluded that all members agreed to the extension to curb oil production. We believe that oil prices will continue to recover, and recommend to stay long the Norwegian krone. Report Links: A New Paradigm For Petrocurrencies - April 10, 2020 Building A Protector Currency Portfolio - February 7, 2020 On Oil, Growth And The Dollar - January 10, 2020 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1 Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2 Recent data in Sweden have been mixed: Household consumption plunged by 10% year-on-year in April. The current account surplus increased from SEK 43.2 billion to SEK 80.6 billion in Q1. Headline consumer prices recovered from a 0.4% year-on-year decline to flat in May. The Swedish krona increased by 0.6% against the US dollar this week. Sweden is benefitting economically from a less stringent Covid-19 agenda. With very cheap valuations, we remain short EUR/SEK and USD/SEK. Report Links: Updating Our Balance Of Payments Monitor - November 29, 2019 Where To Next For The US Dollar? - June 7, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Limit Orders Closed Trades
Highlights The failure of the dollar to break out amid one of the most bullish fundamental catalysts in months suggests that many opposing tectonic forces are at play. Our bias is that short-term and longer-term investors are caught in a tug-of-war. Longer-term headwinds are a deteriorating balance-of-payment backdrop. Shorter-term tailwinds are ebbing global growth. Traders who have become accustomed to buying the dollar as a safe haven should be cognizant that correlations could be shifting amid the fall in global bond yields. The yen and gold remain the currencies of choice in this environment. Despite economic headwinds, the BoJ has historically needed an external shock to act, suggesting the path towards additional stimulus will be lined with a stronger yen. Our bias is that USD/JPY could weaken to 100 in the next three-to-six months, especially if market volatility spikes further. If global growth eventually picks up, the yen will surely weaken on its crosses, but could still strengthen versus the dollar. The reversal in the EUR/GBP is worth monitoring. Aggressive investors can short the pair now for a trade. Feature Chart I-1A Worrisome Development Consider the events over the last few weeks: U.S. President Donald Trump blindsided investors by firing a new salvo in the trade war. China retaliated by depreciating the RMB below the psychologically important 7 level. In Argentina, a heavy loss for reformist Mauricio Macri has sent the peso down almost 40% this year. Venezuela is now completely shut off from the U.S., given continued friction between the regime of incumbent Nicolás Maduro and Juan Guaidó. In Europe, Boris Johnson has all but assured us that he is taking the U.K. out of the EU, sending the pound to near post-referendum lows. And on the global economic front, July manufacturing data was dismal across the board. This is nudging the U.S. 10-year versus 2-year Treasury yield curve into inversion, adding to the recessionary indicators that have accumulated so far (Chart I-1). Both gold and the yen have bounced in sympathy with these developments, but the trade-weighted dollar (either using the DXY or the Federal Reserve’s broader measure) is up only circa 1% over the last month. Had a currency manager taken a one-month leave of absence, this setup would be incredibly perplexing upon return. Has the investment landscape changed, or are both traders and algorithmic platforms sitting on the sidelines given thin summer trading? More importantly, has the dollar lost its crown as a safe-haven currency? The answers to these questions are obviously very important for the cyclical view on the dollar. Is This Time Different? It is too early to tell if the dollar’s muted response is just the lagged effect of thin summer trading, or a signal towards much bigger opposing forces at play. What we can infer is that both short-term and longer-term investors are caught in a tug-of-war, currently in a stalemate. The short-term boost for the dollar comes from the fact that global growth is weak and the U.S. economy has the upper hand, given the smaller contribution from the manufacturing sector to GDP. Meanwhile, U.S. interest rates, while falling, remain among the most attractive in the developed world. Portfolio flows into the U.S. economy is the ultimate link between global growth and the dollar. The caveat is that these bullish factors are slowly ebbing. We have argued in past reports that global growth will soon bottom, if past correlations between monetary stimulus and economic growth hold. Meanwhile, the Federal Reserve is slated to become more dovish, which will remove an important tailwind for the dollar (Chart I-2). The latest comments from Olli Rehn, governor of the Finnish central bank and member of the ECB’s rate-setting committee, suggests that significant stimulus will be forthcoming in September. This should keep a bid under the DXY index. However, investors also understand that other governments are unlikely to sit pat and watch their trading partners wage a currency war. Political pressure towards lower rates is now as high as it has ever been (Chart I-3), a change from the past. Chart I-2The U.S. Yield Advantage Is Fading Chart I-3Political Pressure To Cut Rates But why has the dollar not strengthened more in the interim, given that bullish forces remain present? The answer lies in underlying portfolio flows into the U.S. economy, which is the ultimate link between global growth and the dollar. Everyone understands the standard feedback loop between global growth and the greenback. The U.S., being a relatively closed economy, sees outflows when global growth is improving. This is because capital tends to gravitate to higher-yielding currencies that are more levered to the manufacturing cycle. And during risk-off environments, that capital finds its way back home – the so-called “home-bias” – that boosts the dollar. This has been the story for most of the last two decades. However, things began to shift a few years ago. Following cascading crises (in Europe, Japan and even some commodity-producing countries, for example), interest rates outside the U.S. began to fall rapidly, and the U.S. bond market became one of the most attractive in yield terms. For example, at the onset of 2014, 10-year bond yields were at 4.4% in Australia while they were sitting at 3% in the U.S. Today, a 10-year Australian bond yields 0.9% while 10-year Treasurys are at 1.5%. The implication is that the U.S. dollar has now become an object of carry trades itself, as confirmed by current positioning data (Chart I-4). However, here comes the important crux. It is difficult for the dollar to act as both a safe-haven and a carry currency, because the forces that drive both move in opposite directions. For one, safe-haven assets tend to be lower-yielding, but also during episodes of capital flight, investors choose to repatriate capital to pay down debt, with creditor nations having the upper hand. And given that U.S. investors have already been repatriating close to $300 billion in assets over the past 12 months (in part because of better returns, but also because of the 2017 Trump tax cuts), the dollar’s safe-haven bid has partially evaporated. Traders who have been used to buying the dollar as a safe haven should be cognizant that correlations may have shifted amid the fall in global bond yields. Flows into the U.S. capital markets are instructive. What has been supporting capital flows into the U.S. are agency, corporate, and Treasury bond purchases, with foreign investors already stampeding out of U.S. equities at the fastest pace on record (Chart I-5). This is because the starting point for the U.S. is an equity market that is one of the most overvalued, dictating that subsequent returns will pale by historical comparison. Chart I-5Banks Have Been Supporting U.S. Inflows Meanwhile, cracks are beginning to appear in the Treasury market, one of the last pillars of support for U.S. inflows. Foreign officials have already been exiting the U.S. bond market for both geopolitical and balance-of-payment concerns, but private purchases still remain robust. However, the latest data shows that net foreign private purchases of U.S. Treasury bonds have rolled over from about $220 billion dollars earlier this year to about $200 billion currently. Ebbs and flows in the U.S. Treasury market have historically had a great track record of capturing major turning points in the U.S. bond yields over the last decade (Chart I-6). To be sure, these flows are still positive, with June data robust, but they are rolling over. It is likely that July and August data will be stronger, given the drop in yields. However, long Treasurys and long dollar positions are some of the most crowded trades today. The bottom line is that if the dollar cannot rise under a bullish near-term backdrop, it is likely to fall hard when these fundamental forces evaporate. Monitoring the bond-to-gold ratio is a good way to gauge where the balance of forces are shifting, and the picture is not constructive for dollar bulls (Chart I-7). Meanwhile, currencies such as the Japanese yen or even the Swiss franc, which have been used to fund carry trades, remain ripe for further short-covering flows. Chart I-6What Happens When Bond Investors Flee? Chart I-7Unsustainable Divergence Bottom Line: Traders who have been used to buying the dollar as a safe haven should be cognizant that correlations may have shifted amid the fall in global bond yields. Stay Short USD/JPY Should the selloff in global risk assets persist, the yen will strengthen further. On the other hand, if global growth does eventually pick up, the yen could weaken on its crosses but strengthen vis-à-vis the dollar. This places short USD/JPY bets in an enviable “heads I win, tails I do not lose too much” position. Economic data from Japan over the past few weeks suggests the economy is not yet succumbing to pressures of weak external growth (Chart I-8). The services PMI remains relatively high compared to manufacturing, vehicles sales are accelerating at a 7% year-on-year pace and bank lending is still robust. The labor market also remains relatively tight, with Tokyo office vacancies hitting post-crisis lows. The preliminary print of second quarter GDP growth slowed to 1.8% from 2.2%, but this was entirely driven by the external sector. A return towards deflationary pressures will eventually force the Bank of Japan’s hand, but the yen will strengthen in the interim. What these developments suggest is that the hurdle for delaying the consumption tax is now extremely high. And since the late 1990s, every time Japan’s consumption tax has been hiked, the economy has slumped by an average of over 1.3% in subsequent quarters. A return towards deflationary pressures will eventually force the Bank of Japan’s hand, but the yen will strengthen in the interim. This is because the BoJ will need to come up with even more unconventional policies, something that requires time. Total annual asset purchases by the BoJ are currently running at about ¥22 trillion, while JGBs purchases are running below ¥20 trillion. This is a far cry from the central bank’s soft target of ¥80 trillion, and unlikely to change anytime soon, since JGB yields are trading near the floor of the central bank’s range (Chart I-9). Chart I-8Japan Is Fine For Now Chart I-9The BoJ Is Out Of Bullets It is important to remember why deflation is so pervasive in Japan, making the BoJ’s target of 2% a bit of a pipedream if it stands pat. The overarching theme for prices in Japan is a rapidly falling (and rapidly ageing) population, leading to deficient demand (Chart I-10). Meanwhile, domestically, an aging population (that tends to be the growing voting base), prefers falling prices. What is needed is to convince the younger generation to save less and consume more, but that is almost impossible when high debt levels lead to insecurity about the social safety net. Hence the reason for the consumption tax, which has historically been deflationary. Chart I-10Deflation Is Pervasive In Japan On the other side of the coin, the importance of financial stability to the credit intermediation process has been a recurring theme among Japanese policymakers, with the health of the banking sector an important pillar. YCC and negative interest rates have been anathema for Japanese net interest margins and share prices (Chart I-11). This, together with QE, has pushed banks to search for yield down the credit spectrum. Any policy shift that is increasingly negative for banks could easily tip them over. This suggests the shock needed for either the BoJ or the government to act has to be “Lehman” like. The eventual bottom in global growth is a key risk to a long yen position. However, inflows into Japan could accelerate, given cheap equity valuations and improved corporate governance that has been raising the relative return on capital. The propensity of investors to hedge these purchases will dictate the yen’s path. The traditional negative relationship between the yen and the Nikkei still holds but has been weakening in recent years. Over the past few years, an offshoring of industrial production has been marginally eroding the benefit of a weak yen/strong Nikkei. If a company’s labor costs are no longer incurred in yen, then the translation effect for profits is reduced on currency weakness (Chart I-12). Chart I-11Japan: More Easing Will Kill Banks Chart I-12The Nikkei And Yen Have Diverged Bottom Line: Inflation expectations are falling to rock-bottom levels in Japan, at a time when the BoJ may be running out of policy bullets. Meanwhile, the margin of error for the BoJ is non-trivial, since a small external shock could tip the economy back into deflation. The BoJ will eventually act, but it may first require a riot point (Chart I-13). Remain short USD/JPY. Chart I-13What More Could The BoJ Do? Housekeeping Chart I-14Look To Sell EUR/GBP Tactical investors could try selling EUR/GBP for a trade ahead of our actual limit-sell at 0.95. The ever-shifting political landscape warrants tight stops, but despite all the noise, economic surprises in the euro area are rolling over relative to the U.K., which usually benefits the pound (Chart I-14). Finally, the Norges bank has chosen to remain on hold, though has begun to sound less hawkish. We remain long NOK/SEK but are ready to take profits on any sign a currency war is intensifying, or that oil prices are headed much lower. Chester Ntonifor, Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1 Chart II-2USD Technicals 2 Recent data in the U.S. have been robust: Headline and core inflation both edged up 10 bps to 1.8% and 2.2% year-on-year respectively in July. Mortgage applications surged by 21.7%, reversing prior weakness in the MBA Purchase Index. NY Empire State manufacturing index increased to 4.8 in August; The Philly Fed manufacturing index fell to 16.8, still well above the consensus of 9.5. Retail sales jumped by 0.7% month-on-month in July, up from downwardly-revised 0.3% in June. Nonfarm productivity grew by 2.3% quarter-on-quarter in Q2; The unit labor costs went up 2.4% quarter-on-quarter. Real hourly earnings in July however, slowed to 1.3% year-on-year. Industrial production fell by 0.2% month-on-month in July. DXY index appreciated by 0.6% this week. Consumer prices rebounded in July, mostly driven by shelter, and medical care services. This marginally lowered the prospect for more aggressive rate cuts by the Federal Reserve. Report Links: USD/CNY And Market Turbulence - August 9, 2019 Focusing On the Trees But Missing The Forest - August 2, 2019 Global Growth And The Dollar - July 19, 2019 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1 Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2 Recent data in the euro area continue to deteriorate: ZEW sentiment fell to -43.6 in August, the lowest since 2012. Preliminary GDP yearly growth was flat at 1.1% year-on-year in Q2, even though the German economy stagnated. Industrial production contracted by 2.6% year-on-year in June. Employment growth slowed to 1.1% year-on-year in Q2. EUR/USD fell by 0.9%, following the relatively soft data. However, if the world economy avoids recession, it will be tough for data to deteriorate meaningfully from current levels. We believe that manufacturing data will get a boost once global growth stabilizes. Meanwhile, the euro is currently trading at an attractive discount to its fair value. Report Links: Battle Of The Central Banks - June 21, 2019 EUR/USD And The Neutral Rate Of Interest - June 14, 2019 Take Out Some Insurance - May 3, 2019 Japanese Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1 Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2 Recent data in Japan have been mixed: Producer prices contracted by 0.6% year-on-year in July. Core machinery orders increased by 12.5% year-on-year in June, while preliminary machine tool orders for July fell by 33% year-on-year, from -38% the prior month. Industrial production contracted by 3.8% year-on-year in June. Capacity utilization fell by 2.6% year-on-year in June. USD/JPY appreciated by 0.3% this week. Japanese data was notable healthier in June, suggesting that weakness in July was exacerbated by external factors. That said, long yen bets are in an enviable “heads I win, tails I do not lose too much” position, as posited in the front section of this bulletin. Report Links: Portfolio Tweaks Into Thin Summer Trading - July 5, 2019 Battle Of The Central Banks - June 21, 2019 Short USD/JPY: Heads I Win, Tails I Don’t Lose Too Much - May 31, 2019 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1 Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2 There was a flurry of data out of the U.K. this week, most of which were firm: Preliminary GDP growth fell to 1.2% year-on-year in Q2, from the previous 1.8%. This was mostly driven by investment that contracted by 1.6%. This makes sense given Brexit uncertainties. Exports contracted by 3.3% quarter-on-quarter in Q2, but imports fell 12.9% quarter-on-quarter. The total trade balance increased to £1.78 billion in June. The unemployment rate nudged up to 3.9% in June, but the labor report was robust. Weekly earnings soared by 3.9%. Headline and core inflation moved up to 2.1% and 1.9% year-on-year respectively in July. Lastly, total retail sales increased by 3.3% year-on-year in July. GBP/USD has been flat this week. While GDP data was clearly negative, the drop in the pound is clearly improving the balance of payments backdrop for the U.K. Our bias is that the pound could soon rebound once the Brexit chaos settles. Short EUR/GBP at 0.95. Report Links: Battle Of The Central Banks - June 21, 2019 A Contrarian View On The Australian Dollar - May 24, 2019 Take Out Some Insurance - May 3, 2019 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1 Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2 Recent data in Australia have been positive: NAB business confidence edged up to 4 in July, from 2. Westpac consumer confidence also rebounded by 3.6% month-on-month in August. Consumer inflation expectations increased to 3.5% in August. The employment report was robust. The unemployment rate was unchanged at 5.2% in July; 34.5 thousand full-time jobs and 6.7 thousand part-time jobs were created; Participation rate was little changed at 66.1%. Wages remained at 2.3% year-on-year in Q2. AUD/USD fell by 0.4% this week. The Aussie is a very ripe candidate for mean reversion, once the appropriate catalysts fall in place. Net speculative positions on the Aussie dollar are very close to a bearish nadir. We continue to favor the Aussie dollar from a contrarian perspective. Report Links: A Contrarian View On The Australian Dollar - May 24, 2019 Beware Of Diminishing Marginal Returns - April 19, 2019 Not Out Of The Woods Yet - April 5, 2019 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1 Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2 There is scant data from New Zealand this week: Net migration to New Zealand fell to 3100 in June. House sales increased by 3.7% year-on-year in July. NZD/USD fell by 0.5% this week. We remain bearish on the kiwi due to decreasing net migration, and falling terms-of-trade. Remain long AUD/NZD as a strategic holding. Report Links: USD/CNY And Market Turbulence - August 9, 2019 Where To Next For The U.S. Dollar? - June 7, 2019 Not Out Of The Woods Yet - April 5, 2019 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1 Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2 Recent data in Canada have been negative: Housing starts came in at 222K in July from 246K. Building permits decreased by 3.7% month-on-month in June; Existing home sales increased by 3.5% month-on-month in July. The labor report was poor. Unemployment increased to 5.7% in July. 11.6 thousand full-time jobs and 12.6 part-time jobs were lost in the month of July. Average hourly wages however, soared by 4.5% year-on-year in July, from the previous 3.6%. Bloomberg nanos confidence index fell to 57.8 over the past week. USD/CAD increased by 0.7% this week. A combination of robust wage growth, accommodative fiscal policy, and low interest rates, has supported the Canadian housing market in the summer. Moreover, energy prices should hook up which will benefit CAD. We remain positive on the loonie in the near-term. Report Links: Portfolio Tweaks Into Thin Summer Trading - July 5, 2019 On Gold, Oil And Cryptocurrencies - June 28, 2019 Currency Complacency Amid A Global Dovish Shift - April 26, 2019 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1 Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2 Recent data in Switzerland have been negative: Unemployment rate was stable at 2.3% in July. Producer and import prices contracted by 1.7% year-on-year in July. USD/CHF has been flat this week. The terms-of-trade in Switzerland soared to 128 in June from the previous 117 in May. We continue to favor the franc due to a positive current account, and its safe-haven allure. Report Links: What To Do About The Swiss Franc? - May 17, 2019 Beware Of Diminishing Marginal Returns - April 19, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1 Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2 Recent data in Norway have been mostly positive: Headline inflation was stable at 1.9% year-on-year in July, while core inflation fell slightly to 2.2% year-on-year in July. Producer prices contracted by 8.6% year-on-year in July. The trade balance widened to NOK 6.5 billion in July. USD/NOK increased by 1% this week. The Norges Bank kept interest rates unchanged yesterday at 1.25%, and said the policy outlook has become more uncertain amid rising global risks. The central bank guidance had been irrefutably hawkish prior to yesterday. The current dovish shift reflects more uncertainties in the global market and energy prices. Remain long NOK/SEK for now, while earning a positive carry. Report Links: Portfolio Tweaks Into Thin Summer Trading - July 5, 2019 On Gold, Oil And Cryptocurrencies - June 28, 2019 Currency Complacency Amid A Global Dovish Shift - April 26, 2019 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1 Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2 Recent data in Sweden have been mixed: Household consumption decreased by 0.3% year-on-year in June. Unemployment rate nudged up to 6.3% in July. Headline and core inflation both fell to 1.7% year-on-year in July. USD/SEK increased by 0.5% this week. The July inflation has been the lowest since early last year, mostly due to a slowdown in the prices of transport, recreation and culture, and durable goods. That said, disinflation is now a global phenomenon. We remain long SEK/NZD as a relative value trade. Report Links: Where To Next For The U.S. Dollar? - June 7, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 A Simple Attractiveness Ranking For Currencies - February 8, 2019 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Limit Orders Closed Trades
Highlights Monetary policy remains accommodative in Japan, but will tighten on a relative basis if the Bank Of Japan (BoJ) stands pat. The BoJ’s margin of error is non-trivial, since a small external shock could well tip the economy back into deflation. Historically, the BoJ has needed an external shock to act, suggesting the path towards additional stimulus could be lined with a stronger yen. Our bias is that USD/JPY could weaken to 104 in the next three to six months, especially if market volatility spikes further. We are carefully monitoring any shift in the yen’s behavior, in particular its role as a counter-cyclical currency. If global growth eventually picks up, the yen will surely weaken on its crosses, but could still strengthen versus the dollar. Feature The powerful bounce in global markets since the December lows is sitting at a critical juncture. With the S&P 500 at its 200-day moving average, crude oil and Treasury yields plunging and the dollar taking a bid, it may only require a small shift in market prices to change sentiment sharply. The yen has strengthened in sympathy with these moves, but the balance of evidence suggests the possibility of a much bigger adjustment. Should the selloff in global risk assets persist, the yen will strengthen further. On the other hand, if global growth does eventually pick up, the yen could weaken on its crosses but strengthen vis-à-vis the dollar. This places short USD/JPY bets in an enviable “heads I win, tails I do not lose too much” position. BoJ: Out Of Policy Bullets For most of the 1990s, Japan was in a deflationary bust. In hindsight, the reason was simple: The structural growth rate of the economy was well below interest rates, which meant paying down debt was preferable to investing. Tight money also led to a structurally strong currency, reinforcing the negative feedback loop (Chart I-1). Chart I-1The Story Of Japan In One Chart Much farther down the road, the three arrows of ‘Abenomics’ arrived, ushering in a paradigm shift. Since 2012, Japan has enjoyed one of its longest economic expansions in recent history, having fine-tuned monetary policy each time private sector GDP growth has fallen close to interest rates. The result has been remarkable. The unemployment rate is close to a 26-year low, and the Nikkei index has tripled. But if the economy once again flirts with deflation, additional monetary policy options may be hard to come by, since there have been diminishing economic returns to additional stimulus. Chart I-2Stealth Tapering By ##br##The BoJ Chart I-32 Percent Inflation Equal Mission Impossible? The end of the Heisei era1 has brought forward the urgency of the above quandary. At its latest monetary policy meeting, the BoJ strengthened forward guidance, expanded collateral requirements for the provision of credit, and stated that it will continue to “conduct purchases of JGBs in a flexible manner so that their amount outstanding will increase at an annual pace of about 80 trillion yen.”2 But with the BoJ owning 46% of outstanding JGBs, about 75% of ETFs, and almost 5% of JREITs, this will be a tall order. The supply side obviously puts a serious limitation on how much more stimulus the central bank can provide. In recent years, the yen has become extremely sensitive to shifts in the relative balance sheets of the Federal Reserve and the BoJ. Total annual asset purchases by the BoJ are currently running at about ¥27 trillion, while JGBs purchases are running at ¥20 trillion. This is a far cry from the central bank’s soft target of ¥80 trillion, and is unlikely to change anytime soon. In recent years, the yen has become extremely sensitive to shifts in the relative balance sheets of the Federal Reserve and the BoJ. If the BoJ continues to purchase securities at its current pace, then the rate of expansion in its balance sheet will severely slow, and could trigger a knee-jerk rally in the yen (Chart I-2). The BoJ targets an inflation rate of 2%, but it is an open question as to whether it can actually achieve this. It pays attention to three main variables when looking at inflation: Core CPI, the GDP deflator, and the output gap. All indicators are pointing in the right direction, but the recent slowdown in the global economy could reverse this trend. It is always important to remember that the overarching theme for prices in Japan is a falling (and aging) population leading to deficient demand (Chart I-3). More importantly, almost 40% of the Japanese consumption basket is in tradeable goods, meaning domestic inflation is as much driven by the influence of the BoJ as it is by globalization. Even for prices within the BoJ’s control, an aging demographic that has a strong preference for falling prices is a powerful conflicting force. For example, over the years the government has been a thorn in the side of telecom companies, pushing them to keep cutting prices, given domestic pressures from its voting base. Transportation and telecommunications make up 17% of the core consumption basket in Japan, a non-negligible weight. This is and will remain a powerful drag on CPI (Chart I-4), making it difficult for the BoJ to re-anchor inflation expectations upward. On the other side of the coin, the importance of financial stability to the credit intermediation process has been a recurring theme among Japanese policymakers, with the health of the banking sector an important pillar. YCC and negative interest rates have been anathemas for Japanese net interest margins and share prices (Chart I-5). This, together with QE, has pushed banks to search for yield down the credit spectrum. Any policy shift that is increasingly negative for banks could easily tip them over. Chart I-4The Japanese Prefer Falling Prices Chart I-5Negative Rates Are Anathema To Banks Bottom Line: Inflation expectations are falling to rock-bottom levels in Japan, at a time when the BoJ may be running out of policy bullets. Meanwhile, the margin of error for the BoJ is non-trivial, since a small external shock could tip the economy back into deflation. The BoJ will eventually act, but it might first require a riot point. Go short USD/JPY. High Hurdle For Delaying Consumption Tax Since the late 1990s, every time Japan’s consumption tax has been hiked, the economy has slumped by an average of over 1.3% in subsequent quarters. For an economy with a potential growth rate of just 0.5-1%, this is a disastrous outcome. More importantly, similar to past episodes, the consumption tax is being hiked at a time when the economy is at the precipice of a major slowdown. Foreign and domestic machinery orders are slowing, employment growth has halved from 2% to 1%, and wages are inflecting lower (Chart I-6). This is especially worrisome since the labor market has been the poster child of the Japanese recovery.3 The consumption tax is being hiked at a time when the economy is at the precipice of a major slowdown. Why go ahead with the consumption tax then? The answer lies in the concept of Ricardian equivalence.4 Despite relatively robust economic conditions since the Fukushima disaster, Japanese consumption has remained tepid. By the same token, the savings ratio for workers has surged (Chart I-7). If consumers are caught in a Ricardian equivalence negative feedback loop, exiting deflation becomes a pipe dream. Chart I-6A Bad Omen Increased social security spending: This will be particularly geared towards child education. For example, preschool and tertiary education will be made free of charge. Promoting cashless transactions: Transactions made via cashless payments (for example, via mobile pay) will not be subject to the 2% tax increase for nine months. Cashless payments in Japan account for less than 25% of overall transactions – among the lowest of developed economies. This incentive should help lift the velocity of money. Chart I-7Strong Labor Market, Weak Consumption Construction spending: This will offset the natural disasters that afflicted Japan last year. Construction orders in Japan accelerated at a 66% pace in March. The Abe government’s strategy has so far been to offset the consumption tax hike with increased domestic spending. The thinking is that once in a liquidity trap, the fiscal multiplier tends to be much larger. Some of these outlays include: Chart I-8Japan Needs More Fiscal Stimulus The new immigration law will also help. Foreign workers were responsible for 30% of all new jobs filled in Japan in 2017. Assuming public aversion towards immigration remains benign, as is the case now (these are mostly lower-paying jobs in sectors with severe labor shortages), the government’s target to attract 350,000+ new workers by 2025 will be beneficial for consumption. To be sure, this may not be enough. The IMF still projects the fiscal drag in Japan to be 0.1% of GDP in 2019 and 0.6% in 2020 (Chart I-8). This puts the onus back on the BoJ to ease financial conditions. A combination of easier fiscal and monetary policy will be a headwind for the yen. This could happen if the U.S./China trade war escalates, and twists the arm of the finance ministry. But the hurdle is high for the government to roll back the consumption tax, given significant spending offsets. The Yen As A Safe Haven Correlations do shift from time to time, but one longstanding rule of thumb still holds for yen investors: Buy the currency on any market turbulence (Chart I-9). This is because with a net international investment position of almost 60% of GDP and net income receipts of almost 4% of GDP, volatility in markets tend to lead to powerful repatriation flows back to Japan. Real interest rates also tend to be higher in Japan in recessions as already-low inflation expectations fall further. Correlations do shift from time to time, but one longstanding rule of thumb still holds for yen investors: Buy the currency on any market turbulence. Some have suggested that the BoJ’s asset purchases are pushing investors out of Japan and weakening the safe-haven status of the yen. While plausible, our view is that other factors have been at play. First, tax changes led to repatriation of capital back to the U.S. in 2018. This unduly pressured foreign direct investment in Japan as well as other safe-haven countries like Switzerland. Second, Japan, by virtue of its current account surplus, runs a capital account deficit. This means that portfolio outflows are the norm. This is how it has managed to build the biggest net international investment position in the world. Only in times of severe flight to safety are those investments liquidated and brought home. More importantly, the time may now be very ripe for yen long positions, given rising suspicion towards the currency as a haven. To see why, one only has to return to late 2016. Back then, global growth was soft, the yen was very cheap and everyone was short the currency on the back of a dovish shift by the BoJ. Despite that backdrop, the yen strengthened by almost 10% from December 2016 to mid-2017, even as equity markets remained resilient. When the equity market drawdown finally arrived in early 2018, it carried the final legs of the yen rally. With U.S. interest rates having risen significantly versus almost all G10 countries in recent years, including Japan’s, the dollar has become a carry currency. It will be difficult for the dollar to act as both a safe-haven and carry currency, because the forces that drive both move in opposite directions. As markets become volatile and these trades get unwound, this will be a powerful undercurrent for the yen (Chart I-10). Chart I-9The Yen Remains A Safe Haven Chart I-10The Yen Has Financed Carry Trades Bottom Line: Every diversified currency portfolio should hold the yen as insurance against rising market volatility. What If Global Growth Picks Up? The eventual bottom in global growth is a key risk to our scenario. However, inflows into Japan could accelerate, given cheap equity valuations and improved corporate governance that has been raising the relative return on capital (Chart I-11). The propensity of investors to hedge these purchases will dictate the yen’s path. The traditional negative relationship between the yen and the Nikkei still holds, but it will be important to monitor if this correlation shifts during the next equity market rally. Over the past few years, an offshoring of industrial production has been marginally eroding the benefit of a weak yen/strong Nikkei. If a company’s labor costs are no longer incurred in yen, then the translation effect for profits is reduced on currency weakness. USD/JPY and the DXY tend to have a positive correlation because the dollar drives the yen most of the time. Our contention is that the yen will surely weaken at the crosses, but could strengthen versus the dollar. USD/JPY and the DXY tend to have a positive correlation because the dollar drives the yen most of the time. Meanwhile, large net short positioning in the yen versus the dollar makes it attractive from a contrarian standpoint (Chart I-12). Chart I-11Japan: Better Governance, Higher ROIC Chart I-12Short USD/JPY: A Contrarian Bet Bottom Line: Short USD/JPY trades have entered into an envious “heads I win, tails I do not lose too much” position. Should the selloff in global risk assets persist, the yen will strengthen further. On the other hand, if global growth does eventually pick up later this year, the yen could weaken on its crosses but may actually strengthen versus the dollar. Housekeeping We are closing our short EUR/CZK position with a 4.7% profit. Interest rate differentials between the Czech Republic and the euro area have widened significantly, at a time when growth and labor market tightness could be fraying at the edges. Meanwhile, possible weakness in the dollar will be a risk to this position. Chester Ntonifor, Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 The Heisei era refers to the period corresponding to the reign of Japanese Emperor Akihito from 1989 until 2019. 2 Please see “Minutes of the Monetary Policy Meeting,” Bank of Japan, dated May 8, 2019, p.27. 3 Sample changes last year make it more difficult to have an apples-to-apples comparison for wages. 4 Ricardian equivalence suggests in simple terms that public sector dissaving will encourage private sector savings. Currencies U.S. Dollar USD Technicals 1 USD Technicals 2 Recent data in the U.S. have been negative: Total durable goods orders decreased by 2.1% in April. On the housing front, FHFA house price growth fell to 0.1% month-on-month in March. MBA Mortgage applications fell by 3.3% in May. Conference Board consumer confidence index improved to 134.1 in May. Dallas Fed Manufacturing activity index fell to -5.3 in May. Annualized GDP came in at 3.1% quarter-on-quarter in Q1, revised from the previous 3.2% but higher than the consensus of 3%. Q1 headline and core PCE both fell to 0.4% and 1% quarter-on-quarter respectively. DXY index increased by 0.6% this week. In the long-term, we maintain a pro-cyclical stance, and continue to believe that the path of least resistance for the dollar in down. In the short-term however, there is more room for the trade-weighted dollar to rise before eventually reversing, amid global data weakness and political uncertainties. Report Links: President Trump And The Dollar - May 9, 2019 Take Out Some Insurance - May 3, 2019 Currency Complacency Amid A Global Dovish Shift - April 26, 2019 The Euro EUR Technicals 1 EUR Technicals 2 Recent data in the euro area have shown improvement: Private loans increased by 3.4% year-on-year in April. Money supply (M3) increased by 4.7% year-on-year in April. Business climate indicator fell to 0.3 in May. Despite the weak business climate indicator, soft data in the euro area have generally improved in May: economic confidence rose to 104; industrial confidence increased to -2.9; services confidence climbed to 12.2. Lastly, the consumer confidence increased to -6.5. EUR/USD fell by 0.7% this week. During this weekend’s European Parliament election, the European People’s Party (EPP) won with 24% of the seats. However, 43 seats were lost compared with their last election result. The S&D party also lost 34 seats, together ending the 40-year majority of the center-right and center-left coalitions. Report Links: Take Out Some Insurance - May 3, 2019 Reading The Tea Leaves From China - April 12, 2019 Into A Transition Phase - March 8, 2019 The Yen JPY Technicals 1 JPY Technicals 2 Recent data in Japan have been negative: All industry activity index fell by 0.4% month-on-month in March. The leading index and coincident index both fell to 95.9 and 99.4 respectively in March. PPI services fell to 0.9% year-on-year in April, below the expected 1.1%. Labor market and CPI data will be released after we go to press today. USD/JPY rose by 0.3% this week. BoJ Governor Haruhiko Kuroda has given two speeches this week, warning about the high degree of uncertainty, and potential downside risks worldwide. On the positive side, Kuroda thinks that EM capital outflows are less at risk than during recent financial crises, given a better framework for risk management. In the meantime, uncertainties remain regarding the U.S.-Japan trade disputes, especially vis-à-vis Japanese auto exports. Report Links: Beware Of Diminishing Marginal Returns - April 19, 2019 Tug OF War, With Gold As Umpire - March 29, 2019 A Trader’s Guide To The Yen - March 15, 2019 British Pound GBP Technicals 1 GBP Technicals 2 Recent data in the U.K. continue to outperform: Total retail sales increased by 5.2% year-on-year in April, surprising to the upside. BBA mortgage a pprovals increased to 43 thousand in April. GBP/USD fell by 0.8% this week. The uncertainties of Brexit increased with the resignation of Prime Minister Theresa May last Friday. With a Brexit decision not due until October 31, 2019, the U.K. has participated in the recent EU election. The newly formed Brexit Party led by Nigel Farage, won with more than 31% of the votes. This reflects a growing dissatisfaction with traditional parties within U.K. Report Links: A Contrarian View On The Australian Dollar - May 24, 2019 Take Out Some Insurance - May 3, 2019 Not Out Of The Woods Yet - April 5, 2019 Australian Dollar AUD Technicals 1 AUD Technicals 2 Recent data in Australia have been mostly negative: ANZ Roy Morgan weekly consumer confidence index increased to 118.6 this week. HIA new home sales fell by 11.8% month-on-month in April. Moreover, building permits decreased by 24.2% year-on-year. Private capital expenditure in Q1 fell by 1.7% quarter-on-quarter. Building approvals fell by 4.7% month-on-month in April. AUD/USD fell by 0.2% this week. As we argued in last week’s report, we favor the Aussie dollar from a contrarian point of view. Despite the negative data points on the surface, the recent election result and dovish shift by RBA all support the Australian economy in the long-term. Moreover, the robust job market, rising terms of trade, and Chinese stimulus will likely put a floor under AUD/USD. Report Links: A Contrarian View On The Australian Dollar - May 24, 2019 Beware Of Diminishing Marginal Returns- April 19, 2019 Not Out Of The Woods Yet - April 5, 2019 New Zealand Dollar NZD Technicals 1 NZD Technicals 2 Recent data in New Zealand have been mixed: ANZ activity outlook increased by 8.5% in May, well above consensus. Building permits fell by 7.9% month-on-month in April. ANZ business confidence remained low at -32 in May. NZD/USD fell by 0.6% this week. The Financial Stability Report, released by RBNZ this week, highlighted the worrisome debt levels, particularly in the household and dairy sectors. Ongoing efforts are necessary to bolster system soundness and efficiency, according to RBNZ governor Adrian Orr. Report Links: Not Out Of The Woods Yet - April 5, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 A Simple Attractiveness Ranking For Currencies - February 8, 2019 Canadian Dollar CAD Technicals 1 CAD Technicals 2 Recent data in Canada have been positive: Bloomberg Nanos confidence index improved to 55.7, from the previous 55.1. Current account deficit increased to C$17.35 billion from C$16.62 billion, but it is lower than the expected C$ 18 billion. USD/CAD increased by 0.4% this week. On Wednesday, the Bank of Canada (BoC) held interest rates steady at 1.75%, as widely expected. Despite the recent trade uncertainties, the BoC views the slowdown in late 2018 and early 2019 as temporary, and expects growth to pick up again in the second quarter this year, supported by recovering oil prices, stabilizing housing sector, robust job market and easy financial conditions. Report Links: Currency Complacency Amid A Global Dovish Shift - April 26, 2019 A Shifting Landscape For Petrocurrencies - March 22, 2019 Into A Transition Phase - March 8, 2019 Swiss Franc CHF Technicals 1 CHF Technicals 2 Recent data in Switzerland have been mixed: Q1 GDP came in higher-than-expected at 1.7% year-on-year, from the previous reading of 1.5%. Trade surplus reduced to 2.3 million CHF in April, mostly due to the decrease in exports. KOF leading indicator fell to 94.4 in May. ZEW expectations fell in May to -14.3. USD/CHF appreciated by 0.7% this week. We favor the Swiss franc as a safe haven when market volatility rises. In the longer term, the high domestic savings rate, rising productivity, and current account surplus should all underpin the franc. Report Links: What To Do About The Swiss Franc? - May 17, 2019 Beware Of Diminishing Marginal Returns - April 19, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 Norwegian Krone NOK Technicals 1 NOK Technicals 2 There is little data from Norway this week: Retail sales increased by 1.6% year-on-year in April. Credit expanded by 5.7% year-on-year in April USD/NOK increased by 0.9% this week. Our Commodity & Energy Strategy team believe that the energy market is underpricing the U.S. - Iran war risk, and overestimating the short-term effects of the trade war. In the long run, the Chinese stimulus, dollar weakness, and supply uncertainties should lift oil prices, which will support the Norwegian krone. Report Links: Currency Complacency Amid A Global Dovish Shift - April 26, 2019 A Shifting Landscape For Petrocurrencies - March 22, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 Swedish Krona SEK Technicals 1 SEK Technicals 2 Recent data in Sweden have been mostly negative: Producer price inflation fell to 4.9% year-on-year in April from 6.3% in March. Consumer confidence fell to 91 in May. Moreover, manufacturing confidence fell to 103.7 in May. Trade surplus fell from 6.4 billion to 1.4 billion SEK in April. Q1 GDP came in at 2.1% year-on-year, outperforming expectations but lower than the previous 2.4%. USD/SEK has been flat this week. Swedish exports, a reliable barometer for global business confidence, fell from 133.4 billion SEK to 128 billion SEK in April, which is a total decrease of 5.4 billion SEK in exports, implying that the global growth remains in a volatile bottoming process. Report Links: Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 A Simple Attractiveness Ranking For Currencies - February 8, 2019 Global Liquidity Trends Support The Dollar, But... - January 25, 2019 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Closed Trades
Highlights Solid credit growth numbers from China last week suggest an emerging window for pro-cylical currency trades. However, since 2009, these currency pairs have tended to work in real time rather than with a lag. Continued muted currency action over the next few weeks will be cause for concern. Our favorite currency pairs to play U.S. dollar downside for now are the SEK, NOK and GBP. With the Aussie dollar close to the epicenter of Chinese stimulus, data down under is increasingly stabilizing. Place a limit buy on AUD/USD at 0.70. Improving global growth will eventually put downward pressure on the broad trade-weighted U.S. dollar. Meanwhile, the risk-reward profile for safe-haven currencies has been greatly augmented in this low-volatility environment. Rising net short positioning on the yen and swiss franc is making them attractive from a contrarian standpoint. Feature The unambiguous message from incoming data is that we are entering a reflationary window. Our report last week highlighted the fact that the Chinese economy is in a bottoming process.1 Since then, data out of China has come out much stronger than expected. Export growth in March surged from -21% to 14%, new yuan-denominated loans came in at 1.7 trillion RMB versus 886 billion RMB the previous month, and industrial production in March grew at 8.5% on an annual basis – the strongest print since July 2014. Retail sales were also stronger and house prices are re-inflating, suggesting construction activity will pick up steam. Historically, March data is a cleaner print compared to prior months since it evades nuances from the Chinese lunar new year. As such, these numbers are consistent with a re-acceleration in domestic demand in the Chinese economy in the coming months. As we embrace confirmation that the Chinese economy has bottomed, it will be important to monitor if this cycle plays out like those in the past. Since 2009, the evolution of the Chinese credit cycle has been an important driver of pro-cyclical currency trades. However, in recent years there appears to have been diminishing returns to these trades. Continued lack of more pronounced strength in the Australian, New Zealand, and Canadian dollar exchange rates in light of solid hard data out of China will be genuine reason for concern. Our general assessment is that while the credit impulse in China has clearly bottomed, the magnitude of the rise is unlikely to be what we saw in 2015-2016. Given this backdrop, not all pro-cyclical currency pairs are going to benefit equally. We are long the SEK, NOK, and GBP and recommend adding AUD to the list of pro-cyclical favorites. Paradoxically, the risk-reward profile for safe-haven currencies has also been greatly augmented in this low-volatility environment, but it is still too early to begin putting on currency hedges. Pro-Cyclical Trades Need Broad Dollar Weakness Chart I-1 highlights the fact that pro-cyclical currencies have had diverging performances over the evolution of the business cycle since 2009. The aftermath of the global financial crisis was most bullish for commodity currencies, with the AUD, CAD, NOK, and NZD rising around 20%-30% versus the U.S. dollar. The DXY index was roughly flat during this period, but the broad trade-weighted dollar did weaken. The biggest driver back then was rising commodity prices, driven by Chinese demand and a revaluation of these currency pairs from deeply oversold levels. The weakest currencies were the euro and yen. Chart I-2New Lows In Currency Volatility The second phase of the business cycle upswing occurred from July 2012 to February 2014, using the global Purchasing Managers’ Index from J.P. Morgan. During this phase, the best-performing currency pairs were the euro and swiss franc, and the worst was the Japanese yen. Commodity currencies fared poorly back then. The driver then was monetary policy, with European Central Bank Governor Mario Draghi’s “whatever it takes” put and the launch of “Abenomics.” Notably, the 4% weakness in the DXY did not help pro-cyclical currencies much, given commodity prices had peaked. From February 2016 to December 2017, the upswing was driven again by Chinese stimulus. Commodity prices rallied and the dollar did weaken significantly, which helped pro-cyclical currencies. However, the returns were modest compared to 2009-2010 episode. The yen was flat during the period. Finally, NOK, SEK and NZD have been winners throughout all three business cycle upswings. This time around, more evidence will need to emerge that the broad trade-weighted U.S. dollar has peaked for pro-cyclical currencies to outperform. For now, the calm in developed currency markets seems very eerie, given the flow of incoming economic data. We have highlighted in recent bulletins that most currency pairs have been narrowly trading towards the apex of very tight wedge formations, which has severely dampened volatility (Chart I-2). In the post-Bretton Woods world, it has been very rare for periods of extended currency stability to persist. We eventually expect the U.S. dollar to weaken, but we will need to closely monitor the forces that have so far been keeping a bid under it. Liquidity, Global Growth And The Dollar Most measures of relative trends still favor the dollar. The April Markit manufacturing PMI releases this week showed that while both Japan and the euro area remain in contraction territory, the U.S. reading of 52.4 puts it solidly above the rest of the world. It is true that the momentum of this leadership has been rolling over recently, but historically such growth divergences between the U.S. and the rest of the world have generated anywhere from 10%-15% rallies in the greenback over a period of six months (Chart I-3). So far, the DXY dollar index is up 1% for the year. Repatriation flows have had a non-neglible influence on the broad trade-weighted dollar. Meanwhile, even though the Federal Reserve has paused hiking interest rates, relative policy trends still favor the greenback. The interest rate gap between the U.S. and the rest of the world pins the broad trade-weighted dollar index at 128, or 7% above current levels (Chart I-4). And even today, unless the Fed moves toward outright rate cuts, the dovish shift by other central banks around the world remains an immediate tailwind for the U.S. dollar. It will be important for yield curves to steepen globally as confirmation that other central banks are getting ahead of the curve, which should be a headwind for the dollar. Chart I-3U.S. Growth Leadership ##br##Is Rolling Over Chart I-4Interest Rate Differentials Still Favor The Dollar Internationally, dollar liquidity will need to increase significantly for the greenback to meaningfully weaken. The Fed’s tapering of asset purchases has been a net drain on dollar liquidity, despite a widening U.S. current account deficit. This is expected to end by September, but has already triggered a severe contraction in the U.S. monetary base. Our preferred measure of international liquidity is foreign central bank reserves deposited at the Fed, and this is still contracting at its worst pace in over 40 years (Chart I-5). At a minimum, an end to the balance sheet runoff will steer growth in the U.S. monetary base from deeply negative to zero. A rising external profit environment will be needed for an increase in foreign central bank reserves. Finally, data from the U.S. Treasury International Capital (TIC) system show that on a rolling 12-month basis, the U.S. continues to repatriate back a net of about $400 billion in assets, or close to 2% of GDP. Repatriation flows have had a non-neglible influence on the broad trade-weighted dollar (Chart I-6). Unless these flows roll over and begin to weaken, it will make it very difficult for the greenback to depreciate. Chart I-5International Dollar Liquidity Remains Tight Chart I-6Repatriation Flows Still Favor The Dollar Chart I-7Watch The Gold-To-Bond Ratio The bottom line is that pro-cyclical currencies will need broad dollar weakness to outperform. Our favorite indicator for gauging ultimate downside in the dollar is the gold-to-bond ratio (Chart I-7). Any sign that the balance of forces are moving away from the U.S. dollar will favor a breakout in the gold-to-bond ratio. For now, our favorite currency pairs to play U.S. dollar downside are the SEK, NOK, and GBP. What About Safe Havens? During bull markets, countries that have negative interest rates are subject to powerful outflows from carry trades. The impact of these outflows are difficult to measure, but it is fair to assume that periods of low hedging costs (which tend to correspond to periods of lower volatility) can be powerful catalysts. As markets get volatile and these trades get unwound, unhedged trades become victim to short-covering flows. With many yield curves around the world flattening, the danger is that the frequency of this short-covering implicitly rises, since long bond returns are falling short of spot rates. One winner as volatility starts to rise is the yen (Chart I-8). Investors should consider initiating small short USD/JPY and USD/CHF positions in the coming weeks as a portfolio hedge. Back in late 2016, global growth was soft, the yen was very cheap and everyone was short the currency on the back of a dovish shift by the Bank of Japan. Having recently introduced yield curve control (YCC), the market was grappling with the dovish implications for the currency, arguably the most significant change in monetary policy by any central bank at the time in several years. Given that backdrop, the yen strengthened by circa 10% from December 2016 to mid-2017, even as equity markets remained resilient. When the equity market drawdown finally arrived in early 2018, it carried the final legs of the yen rally. Dollar weakness was a significant reason for yen strength given global growth was accelerating, a negative for the counter-cyclical dollar. But with a net international investment position of almost 60% of GDP, and yearly income receipts of almost 4% of GDP, any volatility in markets could lead to powerful repatriation flows back to Japan. Chart I-9The Consumption Tax Hike Will Hurt Japanese Growth We expect the BoJ to remain on hold at next week’s policy meeting, but the incentive for the central bank to act preemptively this time around is getting stronger. The starting point is that the consumption tax hike, scheduled for October this year, will be disastrous for the economy. Since the late 1990s, every time the consumption tax has been hiked, the economy has slumped by an average of over 1.3% in subsequent quarters. For an economy with a potential growth rate of just 0.5-1%, this is a highly unpalatable outcome (Chart I-9). More importantly, similar to past episodes, the consumption tax is being hiked at a time when the economy is slowing. This week’s data show that exports continued to contract for the month of March. Machine tool orders, a good proxy for Japanese machinery sales, are still falling by almost 30% year-on-year. The Japanese PMI remains below the 50 boom/bust line, even though it has ticked marginally higher in April. Both household and business confidence are falling. The Economy Watcher’s Survey is currently at 44.8, well below the 50 boom/bust line and the lowest reading since 2016. In its April regional outlook, the BoJ downgraded most of the prefectures in Japan, with only Hokkaido receiving an upgrade in the aftermath of the earthquake. As domestic deflationary pressures intensify, this should nudge the BoJ towards more stimulus. This also raises the probability that the government defers the consumption tax hike. However, the yen could benefit from any short-covering rallies in the interim. We expect the BoJ to remain on hold at next week’s policy meeting, but the incentive for the central bank to act preemptively this time around is getting stronger. Bottom Line: The risk-reward profile for safe-haven currencies has been greatly augmented in this low-volatility environment. The rise in net short positioning on the yen and Swiss franc is becoming attractive from a contrarian standpoint. Investors should consider initiating short USD/JPY and short USD/CHF positions in the coming weeks as a hedge. Place A Limit-Buy On AUD/USD At 0.70 Data out of Australia are showing tentative signs of a bottom. This week’s important jobs report showed that the economy added 25,700 jobs, more than double the consensus forecast. Importantly, this was driven by full-time jobs, with a net gain of 48,300. And despite the participation rate ticking higher, unemployment stayed near a six-year low at 5%. Admittedly, the most recent Reserve Bank of Australia minutes showed there was discussion about rate cuts, but this could change if the economy begins to benefit from an acceleration in Chinese growth. Outright short AUD bets are at risk from either upside surprises in global growth or simply the forces of mean reversion. For more than two decades, the Australian dollar has tended to be mostly driven by external conditions, especially the commodity cycle. But for the first time in several years, domestic factors have joined in to exert powerful downward pressure on the currency. The Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) succeeded in its mission to deflate the overvalued housing market, and with house prices deflating by over 5% year-on-year, Australia may already be far along its adjustment path, especially vis-à-vis its antipodean counterpart (Chart I-10). In terms of currency performance, a lot of the bad news already appears priced in to the Australian dollar, which is down 12% from its 2018 peak and 35% from its 2011 peak. This suggests outright short AUD bets are at risk from either upside surprises in global growth or simply the forces of mean reversion (Chart I-11). We are already long the Aussie dollar versus the kiwi and suggest placing a limit-buy on AUD/USD at 0.7. Chart I-10The Aussie Housing Market Has Already Adjusted Chart I-11Chinese Growth Will Benefit The Aussie Dollar Chart I-12LNG Exports Will Benefit The Aussie Dollar Finally, the AUD/USD cross will benefit from rising terms-of-trade. Iron ore prices are already surging, reflecting supply-related issues but also rising demand in China. Meanwhile, Beijing’s clear environmental push has lifted the share of liquefied natural gas in Australia’s export mix (Chart I-12). Given that eliminating pollution is a strategic goal in China, this will be a multi-year tailwind. As the market becomes more liberalized and long-term contracts are revised to reflect higher spot prices, the Aussie dollar will get a boost. Chester Ntonifor, Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 Please see Foreign Exchange Strategy Weekly Report, titled “Reading The Tea Leaves From China,” dated April 12, 2019, available at fes.bcaresearch.com Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1 Chart II-2USD Technicals 2 Recent data in the U.S. suggest a slower pace of growth: The preliminary U. of Mich. consumer sentiment index fell to 96.9 in April. The NY empire state manufacturing index surprised to the upside, coming in at 10.1 in April. Industrial production contracted by 0.1% month-on-month in March. Trade balance came in at a lower-than-expected deficit of $49.4B in February. Retail sales increased by 1.6% month-on-month in March. Preliminary April Markit composite PMI fell to 52.8; manufacturing component and services component fell to 52.4 and 52.9, respectively. DXY index edged up by 0.35% this week. The Fed’s Beige Book was released on Wednesday, summarizing that economic activity expanded at a slight-to-moderate pace in March and early April, with some states showing more signs of relative strength. The Book suggests that going forward, a similarly muted pace of growth should be anticipated for the coming months. Report Links: Not Out Of The Woods Yet - April 5, 2019 Tug OF War, With Gold As Umpire - March 29, 2019 Into A Transition Phase - March 8, 2019 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1 Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2 Recent data in the euro area remain soft: Industrial production came in at -0.3% year-on-year in February, outperforming expectations. April ZEW economic sentiment index improved to 4.5 in euro area. The German ZEW current conditions component fell to 5.5, while sentiment improved to 3.1 nonetheless. The current account balance fell to €26.8B, while trade balance increased to €19.5B in February. March headline inflation and core inflation were unchanged at 1.4% and 0.8% year-on-year, respectively. The euro area April composite PMI fell to 51.3; the services component fell to 52.5; the manufacturing component increased to 47.5. German composite PMI increased to 52.1; manufacturing and services components increased to 44.5 and 55.6, respectively. French composite PMI increased to 50; manufacturing component fell to 49.6; services component increased to 50.5. EUR/USD fell by 0.34% this week. As the Chinese economy bottoms, this should benefit European exports and the euro. Report Links: Reading The Tea Leaves From China - April 12, 2019 Into A Transition Phase - March 8, 2019 A Contrarian Bet On The Euro - March 1, 2019 The Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1 Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2 Recent data in Japan have been neutral: The adjusted trade balance decreased, coming in at a ¥177.8 billion deficit in March. Exports contracted by 2.4% year-on-year, while imports grew by 1.1% year-on-year. Industrial production fell by 1.1% year-on-year in February. The preliminary Nikkei manufacturing PMI improved to 49.5 in April. USD/JPY has been trading flat this week. During the most recent IMF meeting, global finance chiefs have warned that global growth uncertainties remain at a high level. With currency volatility at record lows, any flight to safety could support safe-haven currencies like the yen. Report Links: Tug OF War, With Gold As Umpire - March 29, 2019 A Trader’s Guide To The Yen - March 15, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1 Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2 Recent data in the U.K. have been mostly positive: Rightmove house price index slightly improved to -0.1% year-on-year in April. On the labor market front, 179K jobs were created in February; ILO unemployment rate was unchanged at 3.9%; average weekly earnings came in line at 3.5% year-on-year. On the inflation front, headline inflation and core inflation were unchanged at 1.9% and 1.8% year-on-year, respectively, underperforming expectations. Retail sales came in at 6.7% year-on-year in March, surprising to the upside. GBP/USD fell by 0.5% this week. With Brexit being kicked down the road, the volatility of sterling has dropped, and attention is moving towards U.K. fundamentals. Economic surprises in the U.K. relative to both the U.S. and euro area are soaring. This will put a bid under sterling. Report Links: Not Out Of The Woods Yet - April 5, 2019 A Trader’s Guide To The Yen - March 15, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1 Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2 The labor market in Australia remains robust: Westpac leading index increased by 0.19% month-on-month in March. 25.7K jobs were created in total in March, with 48.3K new full-time jobs and a loss of 22.6K part-time jobs. The participation rate increased to 65.7% in March, slightly higher than expected which nudged the unemployment rate to 5%, in line with expectations. AUD/USD appreciated by 0.7% this week, now approaching 0.72. The RBA published its meeting minutes on Tuesday. The minutes stated that the Australian dollar is still near its recent lower end. However, the strength in commodity prices and improving trade terms are supporting the currency. Report Links: Not Out Of The Woods Yet - April 5, 2019 Into A Transition Phase - March 8, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1 Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2 Recent data in New Zealand are slowing: Q1 inflation fell to 1.5% year-on-year, underperforming expectations. NZD/USD fell by 0.8% this week. The relative underperformance of New Zealand growth could further weaken the Kiwi on a cyclical basis. Our long AUD/NZD position is now 1.6% in the money. Report Links: Not Out Of The Woods Yet - April 5, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 A Simple Attractiveness Ranking For Currencies - February 8, 2019 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1 Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2 Recent data in Canada have been mostly positive: The Teranet/National Bank HPI fell to 1.5% year-on-year in March. Existing home sales in March grew by 0.9% month-on-month, higher than the previous reading of -9.1% while still lower than the expected 2%. Trade balance came in at a smaller deficit of 2.9 billion CAD. Headline inflation and core inflation climbed to 1.9% and 1.6% year-on-year respectively. The ADP number of new jobs created fell to 13.2K in March. Retail sales increased by 0.8% month-on-month in February, outperforming expectations. USD/CAD fell by 0.3% this week. The spring 2019 BoC Business Outlook Survey was released on Monday. It’s worth mentioning that the Business Outlook Survey Indicator fell from a strongly positive level in the winter survey to slightly negative, implying the softening in recent business sentiment. Report Links: A Shifting Landscape For Petrocurrencies - March 22, 2019 Into A Transition Phase - March 8, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1 Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2 Recent data in Switzerland have been positive: Producer and import prices came in at -0.2% year-on-year in March, higher than the previous reading of -0.7%. Trade balance increased to a surplus of 3.2 billion CHF in March. Exports increased to 21 billion CHF, and imports increased to 17.9 billion CHF. Swiss watch exports increased by 4.4% year-on-year in March. USD/CHF rose by 1% this week. The global growth stabilization and improving sentiment in the euro area are offsetting the attractiveness of the safe-haven franc. We are long EUR/CHF for a 1% profit. Report Links: Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 A Simple Attractiveness Ranking For Currencies - February 8, 2019 Waiting For A Real Deal - December 7, 2018 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1 Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2 There is little data from Norway this week: Trade balance in March fell to 13.9 billion NOK. USD/NOK fell after the spike overnight, returning flat this week. The Norwegian krone is still trading at around one sigma band below its fair value, while the economic activity is improving with rising oil prices. Our long NOK/SEK position is now at a 3.6% profit. Report Links: A Shifting Landscape For Petrocurrencies - March 22, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 A Simple Attractiveness Ranking For Currencies - February 8, 2019 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1 Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2 Recent data in Sweden have been negative: The unemployment rate increased to 6.7% in March. USD/SEK appreciated by 0.2% this week. Like the Norwegian krone, the Swedish krona is undervalued, trading at a large discount to its fair value. We remain overweight the SEK, which will benefit from a bottoming in global growth. Report Links: Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 A Simple Attractiveness Ranking For Currencies - February 8, 2019 Global Liquidity Trends Support The Dollar, But... - January 25, 2019 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Closed Trades
Highlights Every diversified currency portfolio should hold the yen as insurance against rising market volatility. However, for tactical investors, the latest dovish shift by global central banks almost guarantees the Bank of Japan will err on the side of stronger stimulus (explicitly or indirectly). Our bias is that USD/JPY could trade sideways in the next three to six months, but EUR/JPY could test 132 by year-end. Carefully monitor any shift in yen behavior in the coming months, in particular its role as a counter-cyclical currency. Investors who need to hedge out sterling volatility should favor GBP calls. Hold onto the USD/SEK shorts established last week, currently 1.6% in the money. USD/NOK shorts are looking increasingly attractive, as will be discussed in next week’s report. Feature The yen has proven an extremely tough currency to forecast in the last few years. Carry-trade investors who used widening interest rate differentials between the U.S. and Japan in 2018 to forecast yen weakness got decimated in the February and March 2018 equity drawdowns. More agile investors who timed the global equity market bottom in early 2016 have been shifted to the wayside on yen shorts, as the currency has strengthened since then. For value-based investors, the yen that was 14% cheap on a fundamental basis in 2015 is 19% cheaper vis-à-vis fair value today. Seasoned investors recognize the need to pay heed to correlation shifts, as they can make or break forecasts. In the currency world, the most recent have been dollar weakness after the Federal Reserve first tightened policy in December 2016, dollar weakness in 2017 despite four Fed rate hikes and more recently, yen resilience despite the equity market rally since 2016. In this report, we revisit traditional yen relationships to identify which have been broken down, and which still stand the test of time. Trading Rules A rule of thumb still holds true for yen investors: buy the currency on any equity market turbulence (Chart I-1). In of itself, this advice is not sufficient. If one could perfectly time equity market corrections, being long the yen will be low on a long list of alpha-generating ideas. Chart I-1The Yen Is A Risk-Off Currency The power of the signal comes when macroeconomic conditions, valuations and investor sentiment all align in a unifying message. Back in late 2016, global growth was soft, the yen was very cheap and everyone was short the currency on the back of a dovish shift by the Bank of Japan (BoJ). Having recently introduced yield curve control (YCC), the market was grappling with the dovish implications for the currency, arguably the most significant change in monetary policy by any central bank over the last several years. In retrospect, this was the holy grail for any contrarian investor. Given that backdrop, the yen strengthened by circa 10% from December 2016 to mid-2017, even as equity markets remained resilient. When the equity market drawdown finally arrived in early 2018, it carried the final legs for the yen rally. This backdrop underlines the golden rule for trading the yen, primarily as a safe-haven currency. Economically, the net international investment position of Japan is almost 60% of GDP, one of the largest in the world. On a yearly basis, Japan receives almost 4% of GDP as income receipts, which more than offsets the trade deficit it has been running since the middle of last year (Chart I-2). It is therefore easy to see why any volatility in markets could lead to powerful repatriation flows back to Japan. Chart I-2Japan's Income Receipts Are Quite Large One other factor to consider is that during bull markets, countries that have negative interest rates are subject to powerful outflows from carry trades. The impact of these are difficult to measure, but it is fair to assume that periods of low hedging costs (which tend to correspond to periods of lower volatility) can be powerful catalysts. As markets get volatile and these trades get unwound, unhedged trades become victim to short-covering flows (Chart I-3). Chart I-3Hedging Costs Have Risen The global picture today has some echoes from 2016. Growth is slowing everywhere and markets have staged a powerful bounce from the December lows. This has been in anticipation of a better second half of this year. In the occasion that data disappointments persist beyond the first half, especially out of China, stocks will remain in a “dead zone,” which will be potent fuel for the yen. This is not our baseline scenario, as we expect growth to bottom in the second half of this year, but it remains an important alternative to consider at a time when Japanese growth is surprising to the downside. If the BoJ is preemptive and eases monetary policy, the yen will weaken. But the odds are highly in favor of the yen strengthening before. Bottom Line: Every diversified currency portfolio should hold the yen as insurance against rising market volatility. The BoJ’s Next Move By definition, any data dependent central bank will be behind the curve, but the incentive for the BoJ to act preemptively this time around is getting stronger. The starting point is that history suggests the consumption tax hike, scheduled for October this year, will be disastrous for the economy. Since the late 1990s, every time the consumption taxed has been hiked, the economy has slumped by an average of over 1.3% in subsequent quarters. For an economy with a potential growth rate of just 0.5%-1%, this is a highly unpalatable outcome (Chart I-4). More importantly, similar to past episodes, the consumption tax is being hiked at a time when the economy is slowing, with growth in the third quarter of last year clocking in at -2.4%. Chart I-4The Consumption Tax Hike Will Be Negative However, things are not that simple for the Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe’s administration. Despite relatively robust economic conditions since the Fukushima disaster, consumption has remained tepid, even though there has been tremendous improvement in labor market conditions. By the same token, the savings ratio for workers has surged (Chart I-5). If consumers are caught in a Ricardian equivalence negative feedback loop,1 exiting deflation becomes a pipe dream for the central bank. Chart I-5Strong Labor Market, Weak Consumption The good news is that the government realizes this and has been taking steps to remedy the situation. At the margin, this is positive: The Japanese government recently passed a law that will allow the largest inflow of foreign workers into the country. There are about 1.5 million foreign workers in Japan today, who collectively constitute circa 2% of the labor force. The importance of foreign labor cannot be understated. Due to Japan’s demographic cliff, foreign workers were responsible for 30% of all new jobs filled in 2017. Assuming public aversion towards immigration remains benign, as is the case now (these are mostly lower-paying jobs in sectors with severe labor shortages), the government’s target to attract 350,000+ new workers by 2025 will go a long way in alleviating the country’s chronic labor shortage. This will also be marginally beneficial for consumption. Abe’s government hopes to offset the consumption tax hike with increased social security spending, especially on child education. For example, preschool and tertiary education will be made free of charge, financed by the tax hike. Labor reform has gone a long way to increase the participation ratio of women in the labor force (Chart I-6), but the reality is that almost 50% of single mothers in Japan still live below the poverty line, according to the BoJ. This is because many of them remain temporary workers. Temporary workers receive about half the pay of full-time workers’ and are not privy to most social security benefits. This has contributed to the surge in the worker’s savings ratio. Alleviating this source of uncertainty could help solve the consumption problem. Chart I-6Rising Female Participation In The Labor Force Transactions made via cashless payments (for example, via mobile pay) will not be subject to the 2% tax increase for nine months. Cashless payments in Japan account for less than 25% of overall transactions – among the lowest of developed economies. Increasing the share of cashless payments will help lift the velocity of money, which will be a positive development for the BoJ (Chart I-7). Chart I-7Money Velocity Is Still Falling Finally, the Phillip’s curve appears to be finally working in Japan, with wages accelerating at a 1.4% pace. Provided the government continues to indirectly put pressure on big firms to raise wages by at least 2-3% in upcoming Shunto wage negotiations, this trend should continue. An extended period of rising wages will help shift the adaptive mindset of Japanese households away from deflation (Chart I-8). Chart I-8Rising Wages Will Help At The Margin The BoJ pays attention to three main variables when looking at inflation: Core CPI prices, the GDP deflator and the output gap, in addition to other measures. The recent slowdown in the economy has tipped two of those indicators in the wrong direction (Chart I-9). This makes it difficult for the Abe administration to declare victory over deflation – something he plans to do before his term expires by September 2021. Chart I-9Inflation Variables Are Softening The perfect cocktail for the Japanese economy will be expansionary monetary and fiscal policy. But despite government efforts to offset the consumption tax hike with higher spending, the IMF still projects the fiscal drag in Japan to be 0.7% of GDP in 2019. This puts the onus on the BoJ to ease financial conditions. At minimum, this suggests that either the stealth tapering of asset purchases by the BoJ could reverse and/or new stimulus could be announced. Bottom Line: The swap markets are currently pricing some form of policy easing in Japan over the next 12 months. Ditto for Japanese banks (Chart I-10A and Chart 10B). Given the recent dovish shift by global central banks, the probability of a move by the BoJ has risen. Any surprise move will initially strengthen USD/JPY. However, given the probability that the dollar weakens in the second half of this year, our bias will be to fade this move. Portfolio investors can use this as an opportunity to buy insurance, should markets become turbulent in the next few months. Chart I-10AThe Market Is Pricing In A Dovish BoJ (1) Chart I-10BThe Market Is Pricing In A Dovish BoJ (2) Corporate Governance, Profits And The Equity/Yen Correlation Once global growth eventually bottoms, inflows into Japan could accelerate, given cheap equity valuations and improved corporate governance that has been raising the relative return on capital (Chart I-11). Depending on whether investors choose to hedge these inflows or not, this will dictate the yen’s path. At present, the cost of hedging does not justify sterilizing portfolio flows (see Chart I-3). Chart I-11Corporate Governance Could Lift Return On Capital The traditional negative relationship between the yen and the Nikkei still holds (Chart I-12). Weakening global growth is negative for the export-dependent Nikkei, and positive for the yen. This is because weakening global growth dips Japanese inflation expectations, and leads to higher real rates. This tends to lift the cost of capital for Japanese firms. Chart I-12The Yen/Equity Correlation Could Shift That said, another factor has been at play. Over the past few years, an offshoring of industrial production has been eroding the benefit of a weak yen/strong Nikkei. In a nutshell, if company labor costs are no longer incurred in yen, then the translation effect for profits is minimized on currency weakness. Investors will need to monitor the equity market/yen correlation over the next few years. It remains deeply negative, but could easily shift, dampening the yen’s counter-cyclical nature. Back in the 80s and 90s, the yen did shift into a pro-cyclical currency. Bottom Line: A dovish shift is increasingly likely by the BoJ. Meanwhile, our bias remains that if markets rebound in the second half of this year, this will be marginally negative for JPY. This could also put EUR/JPY near 132 by year end. A Few Notes On The Pound Recent market developments have become incrementally bullish for sterling. After Tuesday’s second defeat for Prime Minister Theresa May's Brexit deal, and again Wednesday’s rejection of a no-deal Brexit by 312 votes to 308, the probability is rising that the U.K. will either forge a deal for a more orderly separation with the EU or hold a new referendum altogether. Tuesday’s loss was expected because the EU had not offered a viable compromise to the Irish backstop - a deal that will keep Northern Ireland in the EU customs union beyond the transition date of December 2020. Meanwhile, Wednesday’s vote to leave the union sans arrangement was simply unpalatable for Parliament, given economics 101. Almost 50% of U.K. exports go to the E.U. A no-deal Brexit at a time when global exports are in a soft patch, and with much higher tariffs, was a no go for the majority.2 Complete sovereignty of a nation is and has always been a desirable fundamental right. For the average U.K. voter that has not benefited much from globalization, the risk was that Parliament repeatedly failed to pass a motion asking for an extension to the March 29 deadline. As we go to press, this risk has faded as MPs have voted 412 to 202 for a delay. An extension will likely be granted till the May 23-26 EU elections. The preference for an extension has been echoed by EU Commissioner President Jean-Claude Junker, Chief Negotiator Michel Barnier and Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte, all heavyweights in this imbroglio. For sterling investors, what is clear is that developments over the next few weeks will be volatile, but increasingly bullish. Admittedly, GBP has already rallied from its December lows. But long-term GBP calls still remain cheap, despite rising volatility (Chart I-13). Our fundamental models also suggest cable is cheap relative to its long-term fair value and it will be tough to the pound to depreciate if the dollar weakens in the second half of this year (Chart I-14). Chart I-13GBP Calls Are Cheap Chart I-14The Pound Is Cheap Bottom Line: The probability of a no-deal Brexit has fallen. Going forward, risk reversals suggest sterling calls remain relatively cheap to puts. Investors who need to hedge out any sterling volatility should therefore favor GBP calls. Housekeeping Our short AUD/NZD position hit its target of 1.036 this week. We are closing this trade for a 7% profit. As highlighted in last week’s report,3 a lot of bad news is already priced into the Australian dollar, which is down 37% from its 2011 peak. Outright short AUD bets are therefore at risk from either upside surprises in global growth, or simply the forces of mean reversion. Chester Ntonifor, Foreign Exchange Strategist chestern@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 Ricardian equivalence suggests in simple terms that public sector dissaving will encourage private sector savings. 2 Please see Geopolitical Strategy Weekly Report, titled “The Witches’ Brew Keeps Bubbling…,” dated March 13, 2019, available at gps.bcaresearch.com 3 Please see Foreign Exchange Strategy Weekly Report, titled “Into A Transition Phase,” dated March 8, 2019, available at fes.bcaresearch.com Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1 Chart II-2USD Technicals 2 Data in the U.S. continue to soften: The nonfarm payrolls came in at 20k in February, missing the forecast by 160k. Core consumer prices in February decelerated to a 2.1% year-on-year growth. Nonetheless, February average hourly earnings increased 3.4% year-on-year. Moreover, the unemployment rate in February fell to 3.8%. Lastly, retail sales in January grew at 0.2% month-on-month, outperforming expectations. The DXY index depreciated by 0.7% this week. The U.S. economy keeps growing above trend, but at a slower pace than last year. During the 60 minutes interview with CBS last weekend, Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell emphasized that while it is difficult for the economy to keep growing near 4% every year, it remains very healthy and any near-term recession is unlikely. We favor underweighting the dollar as we enter into a transition phase, where non-U.S. growth outperforms. Report Links: Into A Transition Phase - March 8, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 A Simple Attractiveness Ranking For Currencies - February 8, 2019 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1 Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2 Recent data in the euro area have been promising: German factory orders in January came in at -3.9% year-on-year, improving from the last reading of -4.5%. The euro area industrial production month-on-month growth came in at 1.4% in January, outperforming expectations. In France, the Q4 nonfarm payrolls increased to 0.2% quarter-on-quarter, double the forecast. German consumer prices stayed at 1.7% year-on-year in February. EUR/USD appreciated by 1.2% this week. We favor overweighting the euro as easing financial conditions put a floor under growth. Report Links: Into A Transition Phase - March 8, 2019 A Contrarian Bet On The Euro - March 1, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 The Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1 Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2 Recent data in Japan have been negative: M2 money supply missed expectations in February, coming in at 2.4%. Besides, machine tool orders fell by -29.3% year-on-year in February. Total machinery orders were also weak in January, coming in at -2.9% on a year-on-year basis. Lastly, foreign investment in Japanese stocks was -1.2 trillion yen, while investment in Japanese bonds fell to 245.7 billion yen. USD/JPY has been flat this week. A dovish move by the BoJ is likely and it could further cheapen the yen. If global growth bottoms in the later half of this year, this will be bad news for the yen, given its counter-cyclical nature. Report Links: Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 A Simple Attractiveness Ranking For Currencies - February 8, 2019 Yen Fireworks - January 4, 2019 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1 Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2 Recent data in the U.K. have been mostly positive: In January, industrial production and manufacturing production both outperformed expectations, with industrial production coming in at -0.9% year-on-year and manufacturing production coming in at -1.1% year-on-year. GDP growth in January came in at 0.5% month-on-month, higher than expectations. GBP/USD appreciated by 1.1% this week. Cable rallied after the parliament vote on Wednesday. The sentiment remains positive since chances of a no-deal Brexit have diminished. We recommend long-term call options on cable to capture any upside potential. Report Links: Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 A Simple Attractiveness Ranking For Currencies - February 8, 2019 Deadlock In Westminster - January 18, 2019 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1 Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2 Recent data in Australia continue to deteriorate: Home loan growth in January contracted to -2.6%. The National Australian Bank business confidence index fell to 2 in February, while the business conditions index fell to 4. Consumer confidence in March decreased to -4.8%. AUD/USD moved up by 0.4% this week. The housing market and overall economy continue to weaken in Australia. However, the Australian dollar is at a 10-year low suggesting much of the bad news is priced in. Report Links: Into A Transition Phase - March 8, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 A Simple Attractiveness Ranking For Currencies - February 8, 2019 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1 Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2 Recent data in New Zealand have been negative: Electronic card retail sales came in at 3.4% yoy, slightly lower than the previous reading of 3.5%. Food price index in February fell to 0.4% month-on-month. NZD/USD increased by 0.9% this week. We remain underweight NZD/USD, on overvaluation grounds. We are also closing our short AUD/NZD position for a 7% profit. Report Links: Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 A Simple Attractiveness Ranking For Currencies - February 8, 2019 Updating Our Intermediate Timing Models - November 2, 2018 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1 Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2 Recent data in Canada have confirmed robust labor market conditions: The unemployment rate in February came in line at 5.8% while the participation rate increased to 65.8%. New jobs created in February were 55.9k, the strongest since 1981, beating analysts’ forecasts of zero job creation. February average hourly wage growth also increased to 2.25% year-on-year. However, housing starts in February fell to 173.1k, underperforming expectations. USD/CAD fell by 0.6% this week. The Canadian economy, especially the housing sector continues to show signs of weakness, despite a strong labor market. The risk is that overvaluation in the housing market and elevated debt levels impair consumer spending power. While the rising oil price helps, we think the benefits are more marginal than in the past. Report Links: Into A Transition Phase - March 8, 2019 Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 A Simple Attractiveness Ranking For Currencies - February 8, 2019 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1 Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2 Recent data in Switzerland has been negative: Producer and import price growth in February fell to -0.7% year-on-year. EUR/CHF appreciated by 0.3% this week. Our long EUR/CHF trade is now 0.5% in the money since initiated on December 7, 2018. We continue to favor the euro versus the swiss franc as the later benefits less from a bottoming in global growth. Report Links: Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 A Simple Attractiveness Ranking For Currencies - February 8, 2019 Waiting For A Real Deal - December 7, 2018 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1 Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2 Recent data in Norway have been mostly positive: Overall consumer price inflation in February fell to 3% year-on-year; however, core inflation increased to 2.6% yoy. Producer prices also increased by 8% year-on-year in February. USD/NOK depreciated by 1.8% this week. Our long NOK/SEK trade is 2.8% in the money over two months. We continue to overweight NOK due to the cheap valuations and rising oil prices. The pickup in inflation also allows the Norges bank to become incrementally hawkish. Report Links: Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 A Simple Attractiveness Ranking For Currencies - February 8, 2019 Global Liquidity Trends Support The Dollar, But... - January 25, 2019 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1 Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2 Recent data in Sweden have been disappointing: In February, consumer price inflation fell to 1.9% yoy. The unemployment rate climbed to 6.6% in February. USD/SEK depreciated by 1.5% this week, mainly due to the recent weakness in the dollar. We remain positive on the SEK versus USD based on an expected pickup in the Swedish economy and cheap valuations. Report Links: Balance Of Payments Across The G10 - February 15, 2019 A Simple Attractiveness Ranking For Currencies - February 8, 2019 Global Liquidity Trends Support The Dollar, But... - January 25, 2019 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Closed Trades